Welcome to the the Ivey HBA Retail Marketing Management blog. Retail marketing is an exciting, dynamic, important, and very visible aspect of the overall field of marketing. Throughout the year, students will be posting comments regarding contemporary retailing issues. Although this is intended to be used by Bus 4411 students, industry marketing professionals are also invited to join in if they like.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Getting the Most Out of Every Shopper


Based on what we recently discussed in class regarding the science of shopping this article gives some concrete examples of how the right in-store displays can persuade to buy and stresses the importance of marketing in the retail business.


Paco Underhill:

Is one of the first to study how people shop, has been running his own consulting firm, Envirosell, for over20 years. Considered as a retail marketing guru he gathers information for clients by videotaping and tracking shoppers in store over several weeks in time. His clientele already includes big names as Wal-Mart, Best-Buy or Gap and his recent findings are the following:


The newly frugal American:

American shoppers are generally complex, i.e. they are excitable but often creatures of habit, sensitive to influence but harder to manipulate and now they tend to consume more sparingly.

Furthermore he also noticed that people more often make decisions about what to buy when they are out shopping, not before.

Also in better times, when people selected items from the shelf, they usually purchased. Today the average amount of time shoppers spend in the aisles is increasing, by around 20% which can be explained by more careful reading of labels. Generally this might be a positive sign for retailers but at the same time customers tend to more frequently discard items in other parts of the store, particularly near the cash register.

Another interesting aspect is that stores also must get better in persuading existing customers to purchase more.


Examples:

With all this in mind he gives some concrete examples how stores can do a better job through the right in-store displays based on recent observations in Manhattan’s Time Warner Center:

· Organic Food: Explanation is necessary, shouldn’t be too long but at the same time has to transmit that shoppers are buying something valuable. As these products are often more expensive it can also be tried to find creative ways of getting a customer to trade up. Example: “How cute are these”-sign for special potatoes.


· “Woman by the meat counter”: about 60 % of the time she spent there is after giving order. While she is waiting they can give her a lesson on what she could spend her money on next time. When something is written on a blackboard though it doesn’t have the same impact as on a display case glass. Why? Because writing on the glass suggests it’s new! It might be there 24/7 but it looks like someone might have written it 10 minutes ago.

· Pepper mills + sign about grinding fresh paper: Signs are important as the educate the shopper and often justify the price but generally the shouldn’t be longer than a 15 seconds read, which means about 30 words. In this particular case this one had 100 words and they could have than better again.


Basic Guidelines:

There are also some useful “Paco Underhill’s Retail Guidelines mentioned:

1. Shoppers use the area just inside a store’s entrance as a decompression zone. They won’t notice signs put there.

2. Americans naturally turn right as they walk further into a store.

3. Customers respond best when employees great them about a minute after they enter.


Conclusion + Thoughts:

This article may only present some primitive examples of what stores could improve through a minimum of changes and by minor effort. Still it shows once again that many retailers perform pretty much under their potential as they don’t take into account or simply don’t possess the knowledge how negative the impact as a whole can be. Marketing in retailing is often neglected and instead financial metrics seem to be the highest priority. But in order to be successful it is necessary to really understand your customer and investing time and money in professional market research and hiring marketing experts in general should not come to short therefore.

I think we leave in a society which is pretty easy to influence anyway and by knowing certain tools and applying them correctly retailers can certainly lift their performance.


References:

· Business Week, February 9th , 2009 ; p. 45/46

· www.businessweek.com/go/09/shop → Report about Underhill’s videotape analysis

Streetwear clothing...high price + poor convenience + limited stock = BIG MONEY

I thought I would share the complexities I have been dealing recently with while trying to operate a clothing line in a niche segment of the fashion industry called Streetwear.

Wikipedia defines it as, “Street wear is a distinctive style of fashion not to be confused with hip hop fashion. Its roots are in skateboarding and the "skatewear" of the 1980s. It was later adopted as an urban fashion in Japan before growing to an international business. An important element to the style is vintage or vintage-style sneakers.”

For the most part I would have to agree with this definition. The Streetwear industry is a hard one to define to ‘outsiders’ as it is an amalgamation of vintage, skate, preppy, and hip-hop style. Aside from the troubles defining the style, it is just as difficult to describe to others exactly how and why Streetwear continues to grow and have an impact on the fashion industry as a whole.


For those who do not follow the Streetwear industry closely you might not notice its impact on the overall fashion industry, but it’s easy for us die-hards to spot the impacts everywhere. Styles and prints originating in Streetwear brands are constantly being copied by major clothing brands that sell in mainstream stores and even high-fashion brands like Louis Vuitton and Gucci are getting in on the action by collaborating with celebrities like Kanye West to form their own lines that are Streetwear inspired.


What makes retailing in the Streetwear industry so difficult is the complexity of its RVP. It is driven by high price, small selection, and being hard to find.


Part of the value in Streetwear is the exclusivity of the clothing. The clothing brands

that are most popular do not flood the market with their clothes. They are very selective in the shops/boutiques they sell in. These shops need to fit a certain image, carry certain other brands, have a certain clientele, and be run by the right people to get an account. Consumers thrive off this exclusivity and brands can easily be swept into the ‘un-cool’ pile if they ‘sell-out’ and sell at mainstream merchandisers like the Boathouses or Athletes Worlds of the world. To put it in perspective London only has one Streetwear shop – Echelon, which only opened 1 ½ yrs ago, and even Toronto only has 6 or 7 shops.


Not only are there very few Streetwear shops, even in the biggest cities, the few there are have a tiny selection of stock. You would be lucky if you walked into a shop and saw more than two racks of clothing and ten styles of shoes. Even with this small stock, consumers are very loyal to their shops visiting their favourite shops weekly to check up on the few new pieces that may have come in.


Further complicating these shops, which are far and few between and have a tiny amount of stock, is the price. Prices for these products, which ‘outsiders’ would probably thing look like nothing more than a tee or sweater you could buy at Walmart, are sold at a very high premium. Consumers are more than willing to pay this premium, and I believe it goes hand in hand with the exclusivity factor of Streetwear. A basic tee runs from $40-$70, and basic sweater runs from $80-$200. Being on the supplier side of the industry now, I now more than ever see just how much a premium these brands are charging for their clothes. Tees that cost no more than $5 to produce are being sold for as high as $70…now those are high margins.


The one thing I think that attracts people to the industry is the experience that it offers. Consumers very much feel apart of a certain group that are wearing the expensive exclusive clothes from the rare shops that only a handful of people know about. Often consumers get attached to their shop and develop a strong loyalty to it and the few workers that run the shop. Those who wear Streetwear can spot others from a mile away who dress like they do, as well as those who don’t.


More and more, Streetwear is making its way into the mainstream market. Those who are loyal followers are dreading the day that Streetwear is mainstream and sold in malls everywhere, but it is going to happen whether they like it or not. What I have noticed in the last few years is that the Streetwear itself is changing, as its very own products become mainstream. As certain styles become mass produced by ‘un-cool’ brands, the Streetwear industry moves in a different direction to disassociate themselves with those brands.


Streewear is difficult industry to shop in, and even more difficult to retail or produce in. I am finding myself producing clothes for people who do not want clothes that are popular yet not too popular and trying to sell to a small handful of stores that want to sell clothes that are popular, but not mainstream. I have to find a sweet-spot to make my line just popular enough to gain some traction in the market, but not so big of a splash that people would consider it mainstream.


To see my line you can check out at www.classicandpark.com

Can price wars be sustainable?

In October 2003, the largest Dutch retail chain Albert Heijn initiated a price war as a result of decreasing market share. The supermarket chain lost market share to hard discount supermarkets such as Lidl and Aldi who heavily competed on price. Albert Heijn was known for its high prices and consumers were gradually becoming unwilling to pay for the premium prices. This was partially caused by the hard discount stores and partially by the economic downturn. Therefore, the company decided to cut prices significantly for about 100 SKU’s. Consequently, other large supermarket chains that also carried national brands followed suit with even more price reductions. This was the beginning of an intense price war. (Heerde, et al. 2008)

Three year later, the price war ended and the “winner” was Albert Heijn because it increased its market share, profit and turnover the most. However what is the long term effect of the price war? Because it seems that only consumers were benefiting from the significantly reduced prices. Monthly groceries were 40 million euros cheaper for consumers. One major change as a result of the price war is that the rise of hard discount stores has been reduced and the growth of these stores came to a stop. (Baltesen, 2006)

The long term benefit of Albert Heijn is that the company was able to reposition itself by changing its RVP. First, the RVP was based on convenience and selection which positioned the company as a premium supermarket. After the price war these values have changed into price and selection. Even though the company still has a strong reputation in terms of convenience it focuses more on selection. This can be seen in terms of the five different private labels it offers that cater to different segments. Moreover, there are four different store formats that provide different services for different needs. (http://www.ah.nl/)

In terms of pricing, Albert Heijn has been able to change its reputation. According to research conducted by GfK, AH always scored relatively low on prices and discounts. However after the price war it has improved significantly on that subject among consumers. (Thijsen, 2006)

Overall it can be said that Albert Heijn made a smart move by initiating the price war because it improved shareholders’ value in terms of financial performance and reputation wise. Moreover, it reduced the growth of the hard discount stores significantly and eliminated some direct competitors. In addition, the price war resulted into a more consolidated market by ‘out competing’ corner stores and therefore generating more market share for Albert Heijn. (Meijsen, 2007)

This can be said afterwards, however I think price war can be highly risky operations and focused on the short-term. The way I think that Albert Heijn focused on the short-term is the manner in which it dealt with its suppliers. The company put lots of pressure on its suppliers and demanded low purchasing prices. I do not think that Albert Heijn tried to find a compromise with its suppliers but instead used its bargaining power to demand low prices. The reason for this is because the supermarket chain felt that they needed to respond quickly to the current market situation. Therefore, the relationships between Albert Heijn and its suppliers has deteriorated. There are three well known cases where suppliers no longer wanted to deliver to Albert Heijn as a result of the price war. These suppliers were Coca Cola, Grolsch and Peijnenburg. (Elsevier, 2005) Another negative impact of the price war in my opinion is that it has reduced the reference price for consumers while lowering the margins for the supermarket. Hence, this can make a price war a unsustainable strategy.
In conclusion, I do not think that a price war is a sustainable solution to deteriorating market share in general. However, I believe that Albert Heijn implemented the price war strategically. Overall, Albert Heijn’s implementation was not focused on the short because it not only reduced prices during the price war but kept them at a lower level for the long-term (maybe even indefinitely). This made it a sustainable strategy. Therefore, the term repositioning strategy fits better to describe Albert Heijn’s strategy instead of a price war. The only negative aspect of Albert Heijn’s strategy is that it was not quite ethical in terms of putting pressure on suppliers and wiping out a large portion of the corner stores.

References
Baltesen F., “Albert Heijn stopt met prijzenoorlog”, October 21st 2006, NRC Handelsblad
Heerde H.J., Gijsbrechts E. & Pauwels K, “Winners and Losers in a Major Price War”, October 2008, Journal of Marketing Research
Meijsen J., “Vier jaar prijzenslag: de kruitdampen”, October 19th 2007, Elsevier Retail
Thijssen W, “AH zet weer stap in de prijzenoorlog”, January 21st 2006, de Volkskrant
Author unknown, “Prijzenoorlog kost supermarkten 700 miljoen euro” , March 18th 2005, Elsevier
http://www.ah.nl/ (accessed on February 10, 2009)

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Focused RVP Proves Successful for American Girl

While watching a re-run of one of my favourite television shows, Jon and Kate Plus Eight, I was exposed to something that sparked my interest for this blog – American Girl. In the episode the girls went to the American Girl store, created dolls that looked just like them, and ate lunch at the American Girl café, where their dolls were seated in miniature doll chairs. Now, I don’t want to mimic the intro to a typical grandfather’s story, but when I was young I usually received my toys, specifically dolls, in one of two ways. One, I got my older sister’s dolls when she was done with them, or two, if I was lucky I could go to K-Mart to choose a doll of my own. After researching this unique doll merchandiser, it was clear that American Girl has an extremely focused RVP. This led me to ask myself, with the unique RVP American Girl offers its customers, could it be that the days of hand-me-down dolls, and crowded mass merchandiser doll hunts are numbered?

American Girl is a retail store that sells dolls, books, outfits, and accessories to young girls. Unlike some doll manufacturers seen in mass merchandisers -think Bratz dolls- American Girl takes the responsibility of shaping young girls actions and images, through their products seriously, which is evident when examining their mission statement:
American Girl celebrates a girl’s inner star – the little whisper inside that encourages her to stand tall, reach high, and dream big. We take price and care in helping girls become their very best today so they’ll grow up to be the women who make a difference tomorrow.
This statement is key. With the constant controversy in the media in regards to positive self-image for young girls, American Girl hits the nail on the head, considering parents are the actual purchasers of the product and would appreciate this type of sincere responsibility from a toy merchandiser.

With a recorded 23 million visits to American Girl retail stores, combined with 14 million dolls sold through retail stores, website and catalogue , it is clear that American Girl knows what it is doing. The American Girl RVP is unmistakable. With a premium price ($95 for a doll with no outfit), and minimal store locations, neither convenience nor price is the focus of American Girl’s brand. It is selection and experience that sets them apart from the competition. In my opinion, American Girl exemplifies how a focused RVP can lead to success.

Selection
I was blown away with the product selection available to customers shopping at American Girl. Young girls have the opportunity to choose from multiple product lines; historical doll characters, the doll of the year, a bitty baby (smaller size doll), twin dolls, or a ‘just like you’ doll, all of which the customer can choose from 15 different skin tones, hair colors, and of course choose their dolls’ gender. This is a great example of the mass customization we spoke of in class, which allows customers to feel as though the product is extremely unique to them with only some slight manufacturing variations.
The selection is carried over into the doll accessory realm where customers can choose specialized clothing, furniture and accessories for their doll. As an added perk, American Girl offers clothing for young girls in the same styles and patterns as the clothes for dolls. A tailored book also accompanies each doll and games, puzzles, movies and music are also available to shoppers. This array of selection is key when you consider our class lecture on how people buy, during which we discovered that most buying decisions happen on the floor. Thus a key advantage to the selection offered at American Girl stores, especially when children are encouraged to join in the shopping experience, are the number of unplanned purchases. Overall American Girl is unmatched in the doll world in regards to the selection of products they offer to their customers.

Experience
It is however, the experience that makes American Girl stand out from the competition. American Girl dubs their stores, ‘experiential stores’, and that is undeniably what they are. The stores include doll friendly cafes and bistros, a photo studio where a girl can take pictures with her doll to be published on the doll’s tailored book, and last but certainly not least, a specialty doll hair salon. American Girl also accommodates birthday, themed and late night parties for customers looking for an extra-special experience, which run at about $200 a pop! The icing on the experiential cake is what American Girl calls the Doll Hospital, where a girl can take their doll for a cleaning or ‘major surgery’. I would urge you to check out their website , the American Girl experience is unreal.

In my opinion, American Girl proves that by focusing on two areas of the RVP, and really dedicating the direction of your business to those areas, a retailer can provide a stable and unique offering to their consumers. With the increasingly competitive retail environment, setting yourself apart from the competition is crucial. Although American Girl can never replace traditional ways for dolls to reach the hands of young girls, it has definitely created a market for itself in which to succeed. Through mass customization and creative retail stores American Girl provides it’s customers with superior selection and experience, which justifies a higher product price point and continues to keep customers barreling through the doors. I just wish I had been able to experience the American Girl stores when I was a child!

http://www.americangirl.com
http://www.americangirl.com/corp/corporate.php?section=about&id=2
http://www.americangirl.com/stores/experience_index.php#packages

Canadian Tire- the Schwinn bike strategy



Market share over profit?
A critical view on CTR’s Schwinn bike strategy Joachim Harms

“We have priced the high quality Schwinn bikes for $699 and fully reach the semi-enthusiasts! Actually, adding Schwinn bikes to our portfolio led to double digit growth.” That’s what Canadian Tire’s Jody Charlebois told us two weeks ago in her guest lecture. But, is it really the case? Was it the right way to price a top brand at such a level? Wasn’t it wasting profit in order to keep their no.1 position in the market?


An article of Prof Hermann Simon and Frank Bilstein, pricing experts of Germany’s Simon- Kucher & Partners consultancy, raises some doubts if CTR did the right thing: General Motors, for example, declared in 2007 that their attempt to sell more at lower margins in order to gain market share failed. Moreover, they should try the Porsche way: Never produce a car which might not be sold. In this way, exclusivity, a key driver for profits since the first days of economic trade, stays untouched.


In addition to that, CTR seemed to brake a golden rule of marketing: “You never get a second chance to set the first price” By offering the high-end Schwinn bike for $699, the race to the bottom in this particular market just begun. Competitors will undercut these prices within months and we will see prices passing the $600-line. Thus, profit margins of premium products are given up freely!


On the other hand, we have to admit that it all depends on CTR sourcing and costs of goods sold. As we know that they have particular expertise in Asia (especially China) they probably knew exactly what price they can set. Moreover, other gains through adding Schwinn to their portfolio must be seen as well: Adding selection as part of their retail value proposition and strengthening their credibility as the leading bike retailer in Canada. From that point of view, adding Schwinn was an appropriate step.


Anyway, from a pricing point of view, their move was more than risky. Compared to Canada’s independent retailers, who set prices for Schwinn bikes well above $1000, CTR seemed to give up some potential. But in order to attract their customer base, which are the famous semi-enthusiasts (they call them “Paul & Diane”), CTR preferred market share over profits.


If this was wrong, what else to do? Well, according to SKP, companies should reshape their mindset, plan their actions on a long-term perspective and clearly communicate their goals. If not, Simon came to the final conclusion: “To fight on price against ‘free’ is a hard battle to win profitably.”[1] Thus, Business is not the war for market share; it is a strategic game for highest profits. So, giving up parts of their market dominance might boost Canadian Tire’s profit margin even more. In 2007, it was 7.2 % which is already higher than Wal-Mart’s 5.49% in the same period.[2][3] But even better results require ambitious goals. And their official slogan “Bigger & better”, printed on the cover of the 2007 results, is an excellent example for what Simon means with “reshaping the mindset” in order to be more profitable.[4]


Of course, their initiative seems to be the big punch in a saturated market as the Canadian bike business is. And of course, they captured market shares from the individual retailers and preach their Schwinn strategy as highly successful.
Future will show if their aggressive pricing was the right strategy. Perhaps Jody Charlebois will report that in a guest lecture in next year’s HBA 2 class…


Prof Hermann Simon, Chairman, and Frank Bilstein, Executive VP, are both associates of the world’s leading pricing and marketing consultancy Simon- Kucher & Partners (SKP). Running offices in Bonn, Boston (Cambridge), Frankfurt, London, New York, Paris, San Francisco, Tokyo and other ten cities, SKP employs more than 480 consultants and offers over 20 years of marketing and pricing strategy experience.


Source (s): http://www.the-chiefexecutive.com/features/feature1011/, 24 Apr 2007
[1] Article ”Choose profit over market share”, p.3, http://www.the-chiefexecutive.com/features/feature1011/, 24 Apr 2007
[2] EBIT margin, annual reports 2007, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., pg. 41 http://walmartstores.com/Media/Investors/2007_annual_report.pdf
[3] EBIT margin, annual reports 2007, Canadian Tire Corporation Ltd., page 5 http://corp.canadiantire.ca/EN/Investors/FinancialReports/Annual%20Reports%20Library/CTC_AR_2007.pdf
[4] Annual reports 2007, Canadian Tire Corporation Ltd., page 1 http://corp.canadiantire.ca/EN/Investors/FinancialReports/Annual%20Reports%20Library/CTC_AR_2007.pdf

Brand as a Business Strategy

Interbrand Design forum, an American retail consultancy with a world-wide reputation.
has published "The Most Valuable U.S. Retail Brands 2009" in January, ranking America's best 50 brands, according to their power of generating profits in the future.

The brand of a company is no longer only the logo that distinguishes one brand from another, but according to Lee Carpenter (CEO & Chairman of Interbrand), brands incorporate a company's strategy as a whole; It is "the sum of all his or her experiences doing business with that store".
In essence, the brand is revealed in any business decision: Location of the store, layout, design of stores and products, advertising, customer service, changes in collections, even smell and choice of employees. Considering the great influence of a consistent brand strategy, how can this value be measured?
Using financial forecasting, future earnings are discounted to a present value, based on the role of a brand (Reason why people buy it) and the brand strength (risk, related to future earnings, due to market position, coverage and stability). The evaluation of companies, based on their brands might seem to lack in-dept understanding of other factors, such as management, production, supply chain or marketing, but assuming that all these factors are aligned with the creation of the brand, it "provides a way to orchestrate everything about the business... retail is branding at its best and most complex"
In order ro better understand the idea behind, one must have a look at the ranking itself:

1. Wal Mart
2. Best Buy
3. The Home Depot
...
11. ebay
...
16. Victoria's Secret
...
20. Tiffany & Co. 
21. Polo Ralph Lauren
... 
27. Abercrombie & Fitch
...
29. American Eagle

Abercrombie & Fitch can be taken as a good example to illustrate the consistency of such business model.
Founded in 1892, Abercrombie & Fitch is a Ohio-based casual wear-retailer, selling women, men's and children's fashion in its 363 wholly-owned stores across Canada, the U.S. and the UK. Abercrombie is listed on the NYSE and descibes itself as a retailer of "casual luxury". Represented by the logo of a grey moose, Abercrombie sells jeans, sweaters, shirts, and polos of high quality and classic colours with a stylish, yet relaxed attitude, appealing to young customers (18-30), at premium prices.
Abercrombie defines its brand not solely through the clothes, but even more trough the experiences their customers make in the store, as well as the attitude that comes with it. The unique and equal design of all stores does not only differentiate them from other stores, but clearly invites only those customers that feel comfortable in those rather dom stores with loud disco music and strong smell of Abercrombie & Fitch's fragrance "Fierce".
All stores, being white on the outside with black, wooden louvers and a classic, preppy interior remind of the clothes as far as style, as well as rcognition of the brand is concerned. The staff, called "models" is not trained to help or advise, but is in charge of creating a club-like, fun atmosphere, that is casual, yet making one feel special (=cool), compared to any other clothing store. 
Abercrombie intentionally does that to alienate those customers that do not like the atmosphere, in order to make sure that only those that appreciate the experience (brand message) will buy and wear their clothes. The attitude, revealed in stores, reinforces the clothes' image and vice versa.
Having talked to a senior employee of Abercrombie, I was suprised to hear, that the idea of basing the business strategy upon the brand, is exactly what Abercrombie is implementing from its headquarter in Ohio, through a very strict and centralized business network. The brand stands for preppy, casual clothes that are to be exclusive to some degree. Accordingly the stores illustrate that attitude of style and exclusivity, aiming only at a certain target group that will buy Abercrombie & Fitch.
Finally the overall concept makes the brand well recognized, but more importantly, very strong.






Job Not 'Wal' Done; Failure Case of Wal-Mart In Korea



On 22nd May 2006, the American retail giant Wal-Mart had been merged into the Korean retail giant E-Mart of CJ Samsung. This is the second time a huge retail company from abroad was merged into an existing Korean retailer, after the Carre-Four had been acquisted by the E-Land group of Korea. Now that Wal-Mart is officially out of business from their long struggle, There seems to be no available space for foreign supermarket businesses in Korea. How come the two T-Rex of supermarket businesses were so unsuccessful just in Korea? The main reason is told to be the businesses not being able to read properly the unique consumer behavior of Koreans. Well, lets look in to more specifics including the short history.

8-Year business termination

Wal-Mart had entered the business in July 1998, so that comes to an entire 8-Year run. Through that period, they have been engaging in their usual low-price policy. Although they are the world's largest supermarket business, their market share was no larger than 4% maximum. Last year, they had a $9 billion loss in net income.

Wal-Mart is officially the largest business all around the world. There annual sales tops $3 trillion worldwide, which is 1.5 times the Korean government's budget for a year which is $2 trillion.

What did they do wrong?

Mess Up From the Beginning

In 1998, Wal-Mart entered the Korean market by acquiring a company called Korean Macro. But they could not use the name 'Wal-Mart' because a local businessperson in Korea had already registered the brand name and had the exclusive rights to it. Wal-Mart went to the court but the Korean businesses were overprotected by that time, so the judgment was ruled against Wal-Mart. Eventually to start the business, Wal-Mart bought the naming rights from the Korean businessperson for a quite a large number of Won(currency of Korea). It cost them almost a year for Wal-Mart, and this was definitely the set-back.

Disadvantage In Initial Store Placement

Korean Macro was all located in the outside belt of Seoul. Even until now, Koreans have a tendency to move toward the inside of the city, this condition was much worse back then. The expansion of business could not be arranged without the solid income, which they could not acquire in the first place. From 2002 to 2006, they could only expand their size from 15 stores around the country to 16.
However, local Korean retailers had stores more than 3 times the Wal-Mart. Also, their stores were located in diverse locations. From uptown, to downtown, from rural areas to urban areas because they were more flexible with the store sizes, which was crucial considering the massive real estate bubble of Korea.
No Acknowledgement Of Consumer Behavior
The typical Korean supermarket offers a quality consumer experience while the customer is in the store. Employees are trained to provide a service equivalent to that of a department store or the mall. Everything was not about the price.

However, Wal-Mart kept a warehouse like business policy. All their products were relatively cheaper but they were sold in bulks, and had no helpers and special employees who could target the 'Ajuma' segment(mothers aged 35-50) who were price conscious, at the same time who were vulnerable to quality services and special treatment from the employees.

Product Allocation Problem.

Usually shopping is the responsibility of a full-time housewife in Korea, which occured in weekdays. All the stores in Korea, keep the aisles and shelfs much lower than the western stores. The average of Korean aisles is less than 1.7 metres. This was much lower than the Wal-Mart's 5~6 metre aisles. It was definitely inconvenient than the Korean stores.


Bulk Sales Strategy

Koreans are usally intrigued by the colorful packaging. 'Ramen noodles' one of the most popular instant food in Korea, Wal-Mart offered them in 30 noodle pack boxes but oofered them in much cheaper prices, but they had relatively small choices. However, Korean supermarkets sold them in 5 noodle packs for comparably expensive price, but offered them in a colorful vinyl packaging and offered a much larger choice of products. Koreans did not buy food in bulk. This was one thing Wal-Mart missed out.

Not Keeping A Good Relationship With The Suppliers

In western retailing business, the retailer accepted additional money from the suppliers to place the suppliers product in the right place. This was not a common custom in Korean industry, so this led to a bad relationship between Wal-Mart and Korean local suppliers enabling the suppliers to leave for local retailers that offer much desirable in-store placements for no extra money. Wal-Mart had a wrong conception that any reasonable culture would be adapted easily in any part of the world.
Becoming The Test-Market For Worldwide Businesses
Nokia, reponsible for over 30% of market share in cell-phone industry, left Korea in their 3rd year of business. Yahoo, Google, is struggling in Korea while a Korean company 'Naver' 'Daum' splits over 70% of the portal sites shares. Dell does not count for 10% in shares while Samsung, LG, personal business assembled computers count for more than 70% of shares.

Korean consumer code is 'Best service, Best quality, Best Price'. This seems to be impossible to accomplish since low price and product differentiation is on end-to-end.
Because Korean has a demanding success code, the companies worldwide are using Korean market as a test market. A lot of hi-tech firms are lauching testing their products in Korea including automobiles, portable devices, computing devices. They understand that if their product is successful in Korea, it is likely that it would succeed anywhere. Especially IT industry, Korean market is becoming the quality standard. Microsoft is keeping Active-X code in Windows Vista to meet the needs of Korean banking system, and Apple is still unable to launch iPhone in Korea because it lacks the government's Wi-Fi regulation. Also, the world-wide iTunes system's success is not guaranteed in Korea since Korea has powerful alternative services.

However, through thorough understanding of Korean culture and consumer habits, businesses could succeed. Tesco of Britain, recently entered Korea which goes by the name 'Home-Plus'. They are offering everything local businesses are engaging in. And is covering more than 5 % of market share. If Wal-Mart, with their assets and their resources, could have done much better. Personally considering the fact the similar Costco-Wholesales is doing just fine by having huge stores in the city, if their store placement was a little better, they could have had a much happier ending. Wal-Mart just couldn't break the 'wals' down.