On February 4th, Hudson’s Bay Co. announced an internal restructuring plan that involved cutting 1,000 jobs, while centralizing finance and logistics services and consolidating the executive team. Along with these operational changes comes the promise from new HBC CEO Jeff Sherman that the image of the Bay as we know it will be transformed under his direction. Changes began at Hudson’s Bay Co. in July, when they were bought out by NRDC Equity Partners, owners of Lord & Taylor and Fortunoff jewelry and décor. This move seemed ironic; Canada’s oldest company would now be owned by a Conneticut-based private equity firm. But to add to the confusion, the company is now trying to revive its brand image and change its offering in order to be viewed as a higher end department store, with designer brands in a smaller store format.
Traditionally, the Bay has relied on a retail strategy of ‘being all things to all people,’ an unsustainable approach given the migration of consumers from department stores to specialty chains and big-box retailers. Filling the department store gap that exists between Sears and Holt Renfrew, the Bay has never been able to establish itself as having a significant retail value proposition. Customers find it extremely difficult to navigate the eight floors and 900,000 square feet of the flagship store in Toronto, making an offering of selection almost completely counterproductive. The sheer size of the store adds to the brand’s difficulty in achieving focus or value. For example, fashion- friendly boutique Maison B., which opened earlier this year, goes completely unnoticed by most customers in the overwhelming store layout. As well, sales per square foot are estimated to be only $142, which can be compared to a much more efficient $480 at Wal-Mart. In-store experiences are characterized by unenthusiastic employees, confusing checkouts, and unkempt displays and shelving units. These are all clear indicators that change is necessary.
So what has the Bay decided to do? According to Sherman, “everything is being considered” (ie. he is completely unsure), but in the meantime they have gone ahead and hired Bonnie Brooks as president of the Bay chain under the HBC banner. Brooks has spent 25 years in the retail industry, refining retail formats such as Lane Crawford, Harvey Nichols, and leading designer brand stores in Asia. Interestingly, Brooks was also responsible for securing nearly every high-end fashion label at Holt Renfrew (Gucci, Prada, Armani, Dior) and has served as Editor-in-Chief of fashion magazine, FLARE. Her confidence in the Bay’s ability to bring in designer labels such as Diesel, and go up against retailers such as Holt Renfrew shows that she is quite unaware of the fact that it is hard to teach an old dog new tricks. Especially when that dog has been around since the 1800’s, and is one of the best known Canadian brands. I do not believe that simply bringing a high profile name on board will be enough to undo the history that is attached to the Bay, or its image as a mediocre mid-priced department store. It is very hard to imagine buying designer jeans at the same store I would go to if I was in the market for mid-priced linens. Additionally, changes at the Bay will be especially difficult given recent economic conditions, as a recessionary environment has fostered increasingly frugal consumers.
Overall, confusion seems to run deep at HBC. When asked if there are plans to bring Lord & Taylor into Canada, Sherman has wavered on his response several times within the past six months. Having a Canadian Lord & Taylor would simply result in competing with an ‘upscale Bay’ for the same customer, thereby cannibalizing their own strategic changes. Additionally, Sherman has even gone as far as admitting that, “it's hard to make customers return to a store they have abandoned.” Simply reducing the scale of the stores and attempting to upgrade the offering will only create a customer base who is just as perplexed as Sherman is about his own strategy.
Yes, there are shoppers out there who want high end goods from a department store that is easy to navigate and provides good customer service. They shop at Holt Renfrew. And with its established brand image, ubiquitous pink bags and essence of prestige, I do not see the day when these customers will shop at the Bay.
- Deirdre Magrane
Sources:
(i)http://business.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20090204.whbc0204/BNStory/Business/home, "Bay Puts Faith in its Games Plan"
(ii) http://www.thestar.com/Business/article/472415, "Bonnie Brooks taking over Bay chain"
(iii) http://www.torontolife.com/features/shop-girl/, "Shop Girl"
Welcome to the the Ivey HBA Retail Marketing Management blog. Retail marketing is an exciting, dynamic, important, and very visible aspect of the overall field of marketing. Throughout the year, students will be posting comments regarding contemporary retailing issues. Although this is intended to be used by Bus 4411 students, industry marketing professionals are also invited to join in if they like.
Monday, February 9, 2009
Sunday, February 8, 2009
MEN DON’T PEE STANDING UP ANYMORE
As criticizing is a French hobby, I won’t make you discover a brand that you don’t know, I won’t talk about the famous concept of “RVP”, I won’t point out that today using the Internet or being eco-friendly are success keys for retailers, no, today I just want to react to David Steinhauer’s article, because it is more funny. To summarize, his article deals with the fact that men are more effective and efficient shoppers than women. Men only purchase what they need and they spend time in shopping centers as little as possible. Certainly, his thesis is partly true and, he explains, “while I may be stereotyping or generalizing, I am simply writing about my experiences,” so I just will write about my experiences.
Actually, this article treats a major a question in marketing: are purchasers rational? Men are probably not as rational as women. Men can have the same irrational behaviors as women, they can buy clothe on impulse, and they can hang out in mall for hours without finding anything. In regard to the argument that men tend to buy what they need, we find some counterexamples. For instance, I’m not sure that buying a Hummer corresponds to a real need. On the contrary, buying a Hummer would satisfy hidden desires like virility. Conversely, the myth of ménagère de moins de 50 ans, which I would translate by housewife under fifty, is based on women who are very efficient in their purchases. According to a French survey in 2007, French women would be more rational than men when they buy clothes: 40% among men declared that they indulged themselves when they bought garments versus 21% for women.[i] We can argue that some cultural differences could be taken into account, for instance that France is not Canada, but there is a major trend: young men don’t purchase clothes like our fathers
Retailers have two general ways of approaching men markets.
When we talked about
the different solutions to make stores comfortable for men, I thought of a concept coming from Germany, called “Männergarten”[ii] or day-care for men. This idea was born and developed in Hamburg. It is based on the fact that men are supposed not to like doing shopping. In this Männergarten, women can leave their husbands in a bar placed in a mall where men for ten Euros have a lunch, two beers. They can also tinker and watch soccer matches. This bar is receiving a lot of publicity from newspapers such as the New York Times. The concept seems to be profitable and could be copied in malls in Frankfurt, Berlin, London or Paris. Not only such a day-care is demeaning for men but it also relies on archaic clichés of men. Yet markets for men could be in my opinion more promising than markets for women. The place of men is changing in society partly resulting of the evolution of women. Today differences between males and females are getting less and less significant. Some current male behaviors would have been impossible a few decades ago. Men take care more and more of their appearances and this represents huge markets for clothing, perfume, cosmetic firms. For example, the French fashion designer Jean-Paul Gaultier launched two years ago a cosmetic products range for men.[iii] Watch the commercial as it is interesting in an anthropologic way and contrary to what you could think it doesn’t target homosexual. Prospects are better in markets for men than for women. A French survey showed thus male clothing market increased by 1.3% between 2005 and 2006 and amounted to 8.5 billion Euros (13.4 billion Canadian dollars), whereas the female clothing market has known a 0.3% increase in the same period.[iv] As a result, stores can target more products to men in order to increase sales.
Generally speaking, stores should be male-friendly by allowing men to express their metrosexual side in their stores. Stores for males don’t have to be warehouses where men could stay a few minutes before leaving; they should be comfortable places inviting men to stay. Clothing retailers can also use clichés to target this market. The French brand Jules –my post is very French-centered, sorry about that- launched an advertizing campaign based on the stereotype of macho. It is written on this ad: Men are supposed to be a sex maniac… To conclude, I won’t argue that there are not differences anymore in way of purchasing between women and men. However, we have to treat these differences very carefully, otherwise we caricaturize their respective behaviors. The trend for men to take care of their appearances creates new markets for firms which have to change their way of targeting men. Gender differences are a crucial topic, but if we still say that women are less rational than men, then let’s read again Simone de Beauvoir.
I advise you to watch the episode 8 of the seventh season of South-park: "South Park is gay".
[i] http://www.e24.fr/entreprises/distribution/article22160.ece
[ii] http://www.maenner-garten.de/
[iii] http://www.dailymotion.com/relevance/search/jean%2Bpaul%2Bgaultier/video/x4q0fh_jean-paul-gaultier-monsieur_ads
[iv] http://www.franchise-magazine.com/actualite/secteurs/pap-l-homme-nouveau-est-arrive-62.html
What are Retailers to Do?
While surfing the internet for articles about recession and consumer purchasing patterns I came across many sites emphasising that it is ever more important to increase advertising efforts while competitors are cutting back to reduce costs. This will allow retailers to improve market share and return on investment at lower costs when consumers are uncertain and need the reassurance of known brands. However; I question these statements that focus on advertising with regards to metrics such as ROI. I feel as though during such unprecedented times, with weakening consumer confidence and spending, retailers should not be focusing solely on quantitative metrics. Instead they should be getting to know their customers better, seeing that their purchasing patterns have undoubtedly changed due to increased uncertainty. In order to make sure that management is not only focusing on price cuts and margins executives should focus on influencing customer behaviour through emphasising higher conversion rates, improving interception rates, reducing wait times, all the while increasing the amount customers spend in their store.
During a recession consumers still shop and spend money, although they may make different tradeoffs. From talking to several retail sales personnel the most obvious trend is that consumers come into stores tighter fisted. Instead of having the intention to buy Christmas gifts for their whole family they may only be now planning to purchase for their immediate family. However, consumers are still coming in with the intention to buy. Even if people are coming into stores less often they are still entering, which means that it is even more important for management to capitalize on each person who walks through their doors by improving on the overall customer experience.
The longer amount of time a customer spends in a store the more likely they are to loosen their fist and make purchases. Making your customers want to stay in your store does not have to be costly. One of the best examples of I have seen was in a Quicksilver store, placed in the center of the store layout just past the transition zone was a fish tank. This slows the customers down through the transition zone and creates the desired threshold experience upon entering. By slowing customers down they are less likely to head straight for a certain desired item, but may start looking around more and view the items they see in a different light due to the elegant nature of the fish tank they first saw upon entering. Once customers have slowed down past the transition zone there are ample opportunities to retain customers inside the store. A good example of this was in another Australian surf shop, where a few small TV’s were attached to head sets so that customers could watch clips of surfing videos. Newly released videos and large ticket items such as surf boards were placed in close proximity. Not only would this keep male partners entertained and not distracting females from their in depth shopping experience, but it kept customers in the store that much longer. I found that after watching these visuals my boyfriend walked straight to the surfboards, which made me stay in the store shopping for much longer than intended. These ideas to keep customers entertained and in the store break up a streamlined flow of traffic from going straight into the store and out, although they do take up space that could be used to allow for greater selection in a smaller store. Management needs to understand their customers and know if greater selection would be more beneficial than keeping them entertained and in the store.
As noted in class, cutting back on top performing staff on the floor may not be the smartest move during rough times. Effective employees on the floor increase interception rate. The greater interaction a customer has with employees increase the average sale. This is crucial especially now that people are visiting stores less frequently. However, if management needs to cut back overhead and the only way to do so is through staffing cut backs then they must make sure that each employee is used more efficiently. Staff should not be placed in the transition zone or else customers will not pay attention and their time spent attempting to aid customers is useless. Customers do not always know what they want or where they want to go as soon as they enter the store, so if staff can wait until they pass through the transition zone, say 30 seconds, then customers will be easier to engage. I also found from personal experience and staff at retails stores that it is beneficial to approach a customer by saying “hello” and not “hello how are you doing?” This is because by only saying hello most people are more inclined to say “hello how are you?” in response, whereas if a sales person asks “how you are doing?” I will quickly give a one word response and walk away. Creating more effective engagement does not take any more effort. However, it does allow employees to increase the amount of contact taking place in order to increase the average sale. At the same time employees gain valuable information because they get to better understand customers underlying interests and behaviour so that they can relay to management exactly who is shopping in their store.
Waiting time is the final stage and last impression for a customer, so it is imperative to get this last step right. Even if a retail store has done all the above but makes waiting time long then they do not truly understand their customer. No one enjoys waiting in lines, so even if a customer has experienced a perfect shopping trip their impression of overall service will decrease if they get frustrated with long wait times and are unable to make their purchases. Another interesting technique I saw in a large predominant department store called Myer was the use of a coffee lounge near the checkout counters. This effectively brought customers into the store and made them stay longer, but it also acted as a tool to shorten wait times. Customers could go and have a coffee while they wait for the line to decrease, or as I did, made my significant other stand in line while I went and grabbed two coffees to rejuvenate myself after a long day of shopping. I realize not ever retailer has the space or cash flow to build a coffee shop; but even something as easy as serving a sample of a beverage or cookie while customers wait in line at the grocery store would entice customers to continue to wait. This would make them feel as though they are being taken care of while waiting to be serviced at the checkout.
During tough economic times retailers have to be much more proactive with the changing needs of their customers and realize that they can steal market share by doing the little things right in store. When customers are more uncertain and tight fisted they may be more easily persuaded to purchase elsewhere than they are use to if they feel as though their dollar can be stretched further. Such things as customer service, store ambiance, and wait times all help create customers feel like they are getting more bang for their buck.
During a recession consumers still shop and spend money, although they may make different tradeoffs. From talking to several retail sales personnel the most obvious trend is that consumers come into stores tighter fisted. Instead of having the intention to buy Christmas gifts for their whole family they may only be now planning to purchase for their immediate family. However, consumers are still coming in with the intention to buy. Even if people are coming into stores less often they are still entering, which means that it is even more important for management to capitalize on each person who walks through their doors by improving on the overall customer experience.
The longer amount of time a customer spends in a store the more likely they are to loosen their fist and make purchases. Making your customers want to stay in your store does not have to be costly. One of the best examples of I have seen was in a Quicksilver store, placed in the center of the store layout just past the transition zone was a fish tank. This slows the customers down through the transition zone and creates the desired threshold experience upon entering. By slowing customers down they are less likely to head straight for a certain desired item, but may start looking around more and view the items they see in a different light due to the elegant nature of the fish tank they first saw upon entering. Once customers have slowed down past the transition zone there are ample opportunities to retain customers inside the store. A good example of this was in another Australian surf shop, where a few small TV’s were attached to head sets so that customers could watch clips of surfing videos. Newly released videos and large ticket items such as surf boards were placed in close proximity. Not only would this keep male partners entertained and not distracting females from their in depth shopping experience, but it kept customers in the store that much longer. I found that after watching these visuals my boyfriend walked straight to the surfboards, which made me stay in the store shopping for much longer than intended. These ideas to keep customers entertained and in the store break up a streamlined flow of traffic from going straight into the store and out, although they do take up space that could be used to allow for greater selection in a smaller store. Management needs to understand their customers and know if greater selection would be more beneficial than keeping them entertained and in the store.
As noted in class, cutting back on top performing staff on the floor may not be the smartest move during rough times. Effective employees on the floor increase interception rate. The greater interaction a customer has with employees increase the average sale. This is crucial especially now that people are visiting stores less frequently. However, if management needs to cut back overhead and the only way to do so is through staffing cut backs then they must make sure that each employee is used more efficiently. Staff should not be placed in the transition zone or else customers will not pay attention and their time spent attempting to aid customers is useless. Customers do not always know what they want or where they want to go as soon as they enter the store, so if staff can wait until they pass through the transition zone, say 30 seconds, then customers will be easier to engage. I also found from personal experience and staff at retails stores that it is beneficial to approach a customer by saying “hello” and not “hello how are you doing?” This is because by only saying hello most people are more inclined to say “hello how are you?” in response, whereas if a sales person asks “how you are doing?” I will quickly give a one word response and walk away. Creating more effective engagement does not take any more effort. However, it does allow employees to increase the amount of contact taking place in order to increase the average sale. At the same time employees gain valuable information because they get to better understand customers underlying interests and behaviour so that they can relay to management exactly who is shopping in their store.
Waiting time is the final stage and last impression for a customer, so it is imperative to get this last step right. Even if a retail store has done all the above but makes waiting time long then they do not truly understand their customer. No one enjoys waiting in lines, so even if a customer has experienced a perfect shopping trip their impression of overall service will decrease if they get frustrated with long wait times and are unable to make their purchases. Another interesting technique I saw in a large predominant department store called Myer was the use of a coffee lounge near the checkout counters. This effectively brought customers into the store and made them stay longer, but it also acted as a tool to shorten wait times. Customers could go and have a coffee while they wait for the line to decrease, or as I did, made my significant other stand in line while I went and grabbed two coffees to rejuvenate myself after a long day of shopping. I realize not ever retailer has the space or cash flow to build a coffee shop; but even something as easy as serving a sample of a beverage or cookie while customers wait in line at the grocery store would entice customers to continue to wait. This would make them feel as though they are being taken care of while waiting to be serviced at the checkout.
During tough economic times retailers have to be much more proactive with the changing needs of their customers and realize that they can steal market share by doing the little things right in store. When customers are more uncertain and tight fisted they may be more easily persuaded to purchase elsewhere than they are use to if they feel as though their dollar can be stretched further. Such things as customer service, store ambiance, and wait times all help create customers feel like they are getting more bang for their buck.
Shopping at Hollister Co. – Relaxing Beach or Nightclub?

By: Michelle Chandler
This past week in Retail Marketing we discussed the science of shopping and how retailers can significantly improve the customers’ experience and loyalty and ultimately, the retailer’s bottom line. Although branding and advertising do build awareness, most buying decisions are made in the actual store – thus creating an opportunity for retailers to take advantage of customers’ buying behaviours.
Hollister Co. is found in almost every major mall in the United States and has also opened a few stores in Canada (more than 450 stores internationally).[1] The clothing is inspired by Southern California surfing style and does not branch too far from its parent company Abercrombie and Fitch (A&F). Hollister’s clothing differs very little from A&F’s clothing, the differences being their logo (seagull vs. moose) and price (Hollister is slightly cheaper than A&F). However, the style and colours are practically the same (one says Abercrombie and the other says Hollister). So how does Hollister differentiate itself from A&F and other competitors? Hollister’s RVP is all about the experience.
If you’ve never seen a Hollister store or been in one, it’s probably because you didn’t know it was a clothing store. From the outside of the store it looks like a small beach shack from California with great attention to details – palm trees, shutters on the windows, and Muskoka chairs. Hollister has done an impeccable job of differentiating themselves from competitors and grabbing shopper’s attention because of their unique and tranquil entrance. However, after taking a few footsteps into the alluring beach hut, the calm atmosphere quickly disappears. Hollister has focused their RVP entirely on experience; however, instead of creating a relaxing beach atmosphere which would encourage a positive shopping experience, they have created one of a nightclub, which gives the shoppers a negative connotation to both the shopping experience, and the brand.
So why is the shopping experience at Hollister so negative? Our class discussions focused on the shopper differences between men and women and how to make retail environment more male and female friendly. Hollister could significantly improve the retail environment for all of their customers and thus improving their profitability by following my key recommendations.
Who are Hollister’s customers? Hollister’s primary target market is teenagers and pre-teens. However, Hollister clearly does not understand who their target market shops with – their parents! Capital One conducted a survey which revealed that 93% of teens expect their parents to join them on back to school shopping trips.[2] As a result, Hollister needs to make their retail environment more parent friendly (specifically mom-friendly) because at the end of the day, the majority of parents will be paying for the clothing.
The number one problem with Hollister stores is the lighting – or should I say lack there of. The lighting in Hollister is so dim that it’s not uncommon to accidently walk into a fake palm tree or a table of clothes. This makes it extremely difficult for the shopper to know what clothes they are looking at, if they even like the clothes, if they have the right size, etc. As a result, there are always line ups at the change rooms in the hopes that they will have better lighting. However, the change rooms are the same as the entire store – poorly lit. I thought Hollister was trying to portray the image of Southern California surfing and beach shacks, but isn’t California sunny? This is a major flaw in Hollister’s retail environment which could be easily changed.
As mentioned in class, females need personal space while shopping, commonly tested using the “Butt Brush.” If something is brushing up against their behind, the retail environment is too crowded and uncomfortable. In Hollister stores this is always the case, generally because there is too much merchandise in a small area and palm trees are taking up a fair amount of space. Women need their personal space in a retail environment and prefer floor plans that allow for more browsing – neither of which Hollister has.
Furthermore, customers have to search through the entire store to find a mirror – they are practically non-existent, unless you go to the change room. But once again, you have to wait in line for the change room and once you can finally see the clothes in a mirror, the lighting is still dim. This leads me to believe that the return policy at Hollister must be extremely high because shoppers never know what they are buying until they either get out of the store into some decent light or until they are at home.
As well, when a shopper enters a Hollister store they are overwhelmed with the scent of their “SO CAL” cologne which is directly sprayed on the clothing and throughout the store. People can be extremely sensitive to strong smells such as perfumes and colognes. In fact, many fragrance free policies are appearing in work-place environments in both Canada and the U.S. because scents can trigger headaches, fatigue and other symptoms.[3]
People’s senses can be extremely sensitive and Hollister has not taken this into consideration. More evidence of this is the extremely high music level in Hollister stores. A study was done to see how loud music is in malls and the damage it can do to one’s hearing. Using a hand-held decibel meter, it showed a level of 90 in Hollister which is louder than a jackhammer (jackhammers are in the high 80s).[4] This is not only damaging to Hollister’s customers but their employees as well. Does this remind you of a peaceful, relaxing day in Southern California? No. It reminds me of a nightclub – dark, loud, strong smell and crowded.
Hollister needs to re-evaluate their retail environment and the shopping experience it offers. By changing simple items such as lighting, use of space, sound, smell and availability of mirrors, Hollister could significantly improve the shopping experience for their customers and their profitability. Hollister would no longer feel like nightclub but a California beach like atmosphere that they originally intended to create.
[1] Abercrombie and Fitch, Annual Report, http://library.corporate-ir.net/library/61/617/61701/items/295294/Final_AF_07ANNUAL_REPORT.pdf
[2] http://phx.corporate-ir.net/phoenix.zhtml?c=70667&p=irol-newsArticle_print&ID=1026172&highlight
[3] http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/9682.php
[4] http://www.abc15.com/content/news/investigators/story/High-Volume-Sales-A-hazard-to-your-hearing/hj32SEI8QEipUa3VTMsWyA.cspx
This past week in Retail Marketing we discussed the science of shopping and how retailers can significantly improve the customers’ experience and loyalty and ultimately, the retailer’s bottom line. Although branding and advertising do build awareness, most buying decisions are made in the actual store – thus creating an opportunity for retailers to take advantage of customers’ buying behaviours.
Hollister Co. is found in almost every major mall in the United States and has also opened a few stores in Canada (more than 450 stores internationally).[1] The clothing is inspired by Southern California surfing style and does not branch too far from its parent company Abercrombie and Fitch (A&F). Hollister’s clothing differs very little from A&F’s clothing, the differences being their logo (seagull vs. moose) and price (Hollister is slightly cheaper than A&F). However, the style and colours are practically the same (one says Abercrombie and the other says Hollister). So how does Hollister differentiate itself from A&F and other competitors? Hollister’s RVP is all about the experience.
If you’ve never seen a Hollister store or been in one, it’s probably because you didn’t know it was a clothing store. From the outside of the store it looks like a small beach shack from California with great attention to details – palm trees, shutters on the windows, and Muskoka chairs. Hollister has done an impeccable job of differentiating themselves from competitors and grabbing shopper’s attention because of their unique and tranquil entrance. However, after taking a few footsteps into the alluring beach hut, the calm atmosphere quickly disappears. Hollister has focused their RVP entirely on experience; however, instead of creating a relaxing beach atmosphere which would encourage a positive shopping experience, they have created one of a nightclub, which gives the shoppers a negative connotation to both the shopping experience, and the brand.
So why is the shopping experience at Hollister so negative? Our class discussions focused on the shopper differences between men and women and how to make retail environment more male and female friendly. Hollister could significantly improve the retail environment for all of their customers and thus improving their profitability by following my key recommendations.
Who are Hollister’s customers? Hollister’s primary target market is teenagers and pre-teens. However, Hollister clearly does not understand who their target market shops with – their parents! Capital One conducted a survey which revealed that 93% of teens expect their parents to join them on back to school shopping trips.[2] As a result, Hollister needs to make their retail environment more parent friendly (specifically mom-friendly) because at the end of the day, the majority of parents will be paying for the clothing.
The number one problem with Hollister stores is the lighting – or should I say lack there of. The lighting in Hollister is so dim that it’s not uncommon to accidently walk into a fake palm tree or a table of clothes. This makes it extremely difficult for the shopper to know what clothes they are looking at, if they even like the clothes, if they have the right size, etc. As a result, there are always line ups at the change rooms in the hopes that they will have better lighting. However, the change rooms are the same as the entire store – poorly lit. I thought Hollister was trying to portray the image of Southern California surfing and beach shacks, but isn’t California sunny? This is a major flaw in Hollister’s retail environment which could be easily changed.
As mentioned in class, females need personal space while shopping, commonly tested using the “Butt Brush.” If something is brushing up against their behind, the retail environment is too crowded and uncomfortable. In Hollister stores this is always the case, generally because there is too much merchandise in a small area and palm trees are taking up a fair amount of space. Women need their personal space in a retail environment and prefer floor plans that allow for more browsing – neither of which Hollister has.
Furthermore, customers have to search through the entire store to find a mirror – they are practically non-existent, unless you go to the change room. But once again, you have to wait in line for the change room and once you can finally see the clothes in a mirror, the lighting is still dim. This leads me to believe that the return policy at Hollister must be extremely high because shoppers never know what they are buying until they either get out of the store into some decent light or until they are at home.
As well, when a shopper enters a Hollister store they are overwhelmed with the scent of their “SO CAL” cologne which is directly sprayed on the clothing and throughout the store. People can be extremely sensitive to strong smells such as perfumes and colognes. In fact, many fragrance free policies are appearing in work-place environments in both Canada and the U.S. because scents can trigger headaches, fatigue and other symptoms.[3]
People’s senses can be extremely sensitive and Hollister has not taken this into consideration. More evidence of this is the extremely high music level in Hollister stores. A study was done to see how loud music is in malls and the damage it can do to one’s hearing. Using a hand-held decibel meter, it showed a level of 90 in Hollister which is louder than a jackhammer (jackhammers are in the high 80s).[4] This is not only damaging to Hollister’s customers but their employees as well. Does this remind you of a peaceful, relaxing day in Southern California? No. It reminds me of a nightclub – dark, loud, strong smell and crowded.
Hollister needs to re-evaluate their retail environment and the shopping experience it offers. By changing simple items such as lighting, use of space, sound, smell and availability of mirrors, Hollister could significantly improve the shopping experience for their customers and their profitability. Hollister would no longer feel like nightclub but a California beach like atmosphere that they originally intended to create.
[1] Abercrombie and Fitch, Annual Report, http://library.corporate-ir.net/library/61/617/61701/items/295294/Final_AF_07ANNUAL_REPORT.pdf
[2] http://phx.corporate-ir.net/phoenix.zhtml?c=70667&p=irol-newsArticle_print&ID=1026172&highlight
[3] http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/9682.php
[4] http://www.abc15.com/content/news/investigators/story/High-Volume-Sales-A-hazard-to-your-hearing/hj32SEI8QEipUa3VTMsWyA.cspx
When stereotypes help to survive

Hermès, a company founded in the mid 1850’s, is one of the icon of French Luxury. Like every other firm, it has been affected by the crisis; unlike some of you who seem to worry about the future of the luxury industry, in the short run as well as in the long run, I have no doubts that this industry will survive the crisis : on Feb, 6th 2009, the firm published sale figures of last semester : in spite of the gloomy economical environment, sales have been growing in Europe and in North America. Why such results? Which marketing strategy does Hermès follow in order to remain profitable? Hermès has focused on its reputation of excellence and kept is strategy of “no marketing”!
Hermès is an old traditional family-owned business, whose core product was first leather industry for horse riding and then it diversified so that the brand now provides perfumes, hats, home furniture, clothes, and silk products ( like the famous “carré Hermès”, in The Devil wears Prada…).It is known for the very high quality of its products; the firm has progressively integrated the craftsmen that work for it, in order to ensure this reputation of excellence: the Kelly bag, named after Princess Grace Kelly, is completely hand-made. The silk available in every single Hermès ‘s store all over the world comes from a single manufactory near Lyon, which is a town historically known for its fine silk products. This feature enables the brand to avoid aggressive advertising, unlike PPR (another French brand that owns Gucci, Yves Saint Laurent, etc) who highly count on marketing.
Hermès has always implemented a paradoxical strategy which could be summarize as follows: the less visible, the more valuable
As far as Retail value Proposition is concerned, I would say that Hermès ‘s strength consists in Selection and Experience; last year, the firm abandoned a product named “fourre-tout” –a sort of hold all- because it did not match the standards Hermes wants to embodies. As Experience is concerned, just enter a store and you will feel like entering an old aristocratic house, with wooden floor, fine porcelain on the wall, beautiful furniture… Coming into such a store makes you feel like being part of Hermès history : the firm sells you a part of the myth that helps it to stay alive: its French being!
This is is the last but not least strength of the brand :” France” has a very special sound abroad; it seems that France means Paris, which means elegance, love and luxury. This deeply entrenched cliché is one of the strongest comparative advantage of Hermès that enables the brand to stand when many firms stumble. The dream you can see in people’s eyes when they think about France is enshrined in a brand such as Hermès and ensures it most of its succes.
[i] http://www.lesechos.fr/formations/marketing/articles/article_10_7.htm
Saturday, February 7, 2009
Potential of Online Retailing
By: Pavla Grigarova
Although the state of the world economy is so poor, the biggest online retailer Amazon.com, Inc is experiencing its best period and describing the last Christmas holidays as the best aseason ever. A lot of retailers are recently in serious troubles, struggling with considerable losses, whereas Amazon is enjoying its high revenues.
Amazon.com, Inc is the America’s biggest online retailer, founded in 1994, launched in 1995 as an online bookstore. However, it started to diversify its product lines very soon and today it offers a wide range of products from music, movies, computer software to furniture, food, toys etc. Nowadays serves worldwide with special websites established for Canada, United Kingdom, Germany, France, China and Japan. According to Compete.com survey Amazon was able to attract more than 615 million visitors in the year 2008, which was e.g. twice as much as walmart.com.
Unlike other companies, which complained about their revenues during the holiday season, Amazon stated a 44% growth in sold items on its busiest day over the year 2007. Concretely, its customers ordered more than 6.3 million items on December 15.[1] Among the best selling products were included Nintendo Wii game console, Samsung's 52-inch LCD HDTV and Apple Inc.'s iPod touch. The surprising results reflected also in rise of the value of Amazons shares, which increased after the announcement of the last quarter of 2008 revenues by 14 %.[2]
The situation was not always that favorable though. It took quite a long time to Amazon to get from red numbers, as it did not make a profit until 2002. It was necessary to wait for the customers to gain trust in e-commerce. Finally after years of existence, Amazon obtained reputation for good prices, broad selection and convenience.
Question is whether these results are just success of this online shopping giant or if it indicates strength in online commerce in general. Most of the analysts state that the current economy is favoring discount retailers, both online and offline. Amazon is being compared to Wal-Mart in the online world, which was one of the few traditional retailers, whose revenue has risen this holiday season over the last one. In general, figures are not very pleasant. Online sales fell 2.3 % compared with the 2007 holiday season, while retail sales overall fell 5.5 %.
If speaking about online retailers' sales as such, they tend to grow much faster than those of brick-and-mortar retailers. However the difference narrowed this year. The explanation for this is because shoppers tend to go to stores for necessities and online for more expensive purchases. And in an economic downturn, consumers buy rather the most needed goods and save on more luxury items.
[1] http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Amazon-says-2008-holiday-apf-13918688.html
[2] http://finweb.ihned.cz/c1-33658780-temer-ctvrt-miliardy-dolaru-zisku-amazon-prijemne-prekvapil
Although the state of the world economy is so poor, the biggest online retailer Amazon.com, Inc is experiencing its best period and describing the last Christmas holidays as the best aseason ever. A lot of retailers are recently in serious troubles, struggling with considerable losses, whereas Amazon is enjoying its high revenues. Amazon.com, Inc is the America’s biggest online retailer, founded in 1994, launched in 1995 as an online bookstore. However, it started to diversify its product lines very soon and today it offers a wide range of products from music, movies, computer software to furniture, food, toys etc. Nowadays serves worldwide with special websites established for Canada, United Kingdom, Germany, France, China and Japan. According to Compete.com survey Amazon was able to attract more than 615 million visitors in the year 2008, which was e.g. twice as much as walmart.com.
Unlike other companies, which complained about their revenues during the holiday season, Amazon stated a 44% growth in sold items on its busiest day over the year 2007. Concretely, its customers ordered more than 6.3 million items on December 15.[1] Among the best selling products were included Nintendo Wii game console, Samsung's 52-inch LCD HDTV and Apple Inc.'s iPod touch. The surprising results reflected also in rise of the value of Amazons shares, which increased after the announcement of the last quarter of 2008 revenues by 14 %.[2]
The situation was not always that favorable though. It took quite a long time to Amazon to get from red numbers, as it did not make a profit until 2002. It was necessary to wait for the customers to gain trust in e-commerce. Finally after years of existence, Amazon obtained reputation for good prices, broad selection and convenience.
Question is whether these results are just success of this online shopping giant or if it indicates strength in online commerce in general. Most of the analysts state that the current economy is favoring discount retailers, both online and offline. Amazon is being compared to Wal-Mart in the online world, which was one of the few traditional retailers, whose revenue has risen this holiday season over the last one. In general, figures are not very pleasant. Online sales fell 2.3 % compared with the 2007 holiday season, while retail sales overall fell 5.5 %.
If speaking about online retailers' sales as such, they tend to grow much faster than those of brick-and-mortar retailers. However the difference narrowed this year. The explanation for this is because shoppers tend to go to stores for necessities and online for more expensive purchases. And in an economic downturn, consumers buy rather the most needed goods and save on more luxury items.
[1] http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Amazon-says-2008-holiday-apf-13918688.html
[2] http://finweb.ihned.cz/c1-33658780-temer-ctvrt-miliardy-dolaru-zisku-amazon-prijemne-prekvapil
Social Retailing. . . The Time is Now!

This week in class we discussed the science of shopping. We learned that people are more likely to purchase impulsively if they pay with a debit or credit card and that most of our purchases are unplanned. We learned that women are browsers and like to shop in groups, while men are impatient and want to “get in and out”. Both sexes are not a fan of lines. We also discussed how we could make the retail environment friendlier. Some suggestions were: to put things that guys like together, simplify the process, and to encourage women to shop with friends.
We also discussed how imperative it is to get consumers’ attention. While the average attention span of consumers continues to decrease (I know mine has at least!), I was surprised to learn that less than 40% of retailers have an online presence. In a world full of clutter, it would seem to me that retailers should have a good understanding of consumer trends — which includes buying behaviors both in-stores and online. Many retailers have mastered the science behind increasing in-store sales—through in-store promotions, product placement and lighting, to name a few. However, very few retailers have mastered the digital world.
Social media is increasingly changing the way that consumers think as well as the way that they make purchasing decisions [1]. Members of Gen Y (those born after 1978) are more immersed in online and mobile activities than any other generation, according to 2008 research from shopping comparison site PriceGrabber. Over 85% of Gen Y respondents claimed they participated in social networking, and 57% reported involvement with blogs [2]. To stay relevant, retailers must consider creating and implementing marketing strategies that involve social media. Retailers need to begin thinking about the online shopping experience and consumer buying behaviors with the same depth that they have given to in-store.
It would seem to me that retailers offering their products online would offer multiple benefits to consumers (such as: no lines, “butt space”, convenience, and not having to worry about the “wimp factor”) while also benefiting the retailer by generating increased revenues (consumers spend more when purchasing with credit cards). However, retailers may be reluctant to dive head first and make a significant investment in online infrastructure, as the current average conversion rate (converting a browser into a shopper) for e-commerce websites sits at around 2% [3]. Yet, this conversion rate is strikingly low because most online retailers are ignoring the social dimension of shopping—one which in-store retailers have been able to perfect. As discussed in class, at some stores, mirrors are placed purposefully outside the changing room to enable either a friend or a salesperson to come over and compliment a shopper on their outfit; where as, in the past online retailers have tailored their websites to the solo shopper. But, today’s shopper is dubbed a “social gatherer”—they are looking for more interaction with people when they shop online [4].In my opinion, the reason that online purchases, relative to in-store purchases is so low, is because we don’t have that reassurance that we need to buy the item. As social beings, we like opinions.
To address this issue, a very recent trend has emerged in the online retail industry: social shopping. Social networking is popular online. So is shopping. It makes perfect sense to combine the two. John P. Mello Jr., from E-Commerce Times says it best “online vendors of goods and services that ignore the social dimension of shopping are ignoring a potentially large revenue component and are leaving money on the table” [5]. I happen to agree with him. A retailer that is able to incorporate the social networking aspect into the fabric of an online retail store will surely be able to increase profits. Kaboodle (www.kaboodle.com), an online store, has led the way in social shopping. Not only does the website feature brand name products from leading retailers, it also incorporates a social networking environment. Shoppers are able to create a profile, and using the wisdom of crowds, users communicate and aggregate information about products, prices, and deals.
So, why would a retailer want to give a customer anything that could distract them from shopping? The answer is simple—shopping isn’t just shopping. The very nature of shopping is community-driven. Think about your last trip to the shopping mall. You don’t just go there to ring a cash register— they are places to go, to be seen and to see things. The online experience needs to be more social to reflect the changing needs of consumers—if it is; people are likely to spend more.
[1] http://www.emarketer.com/Article.aspx?id=1006593
[2] Ibid
[3] http://www.twistimage.com/blog/archives/social-media-and-the-reluctant-retailer/
[4] http://social-media-optimization.com/2007/06/social-retailing-the-future-of-retail-online/
[5] http://www.ecommercetimes.com/rsstory/57555.html
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)