Welcome to the the Ivey HBA Retail Marketing Management blog. Retail marketing is an exciting, dynamic, important, and very visible aspect of the overall field of marketing. Throughout the year, students will be posting comments regarding contemporary retailing issues. Although this is intended to be used by Bus 4411 students, industry marketing professionals are also invited to join in if they like.

Saturday, February 7, 2009

supermarket fashion


It seems that economic downturn can never get in the way of fashion. Industry observers forecast that the online fashion sector will grow to 13 per cent of the total clothing market and be worth £6bn by 2016. In spite of the downturn, online fashion retailer Asos has demonstrated the validity of forecast by recorded soaring sales. {1}While luxury brands such as Chanel have been suffering from the huge fall in their sales, supermarket giants are looking for their way to capture that loss.

After Wal-Mart showcased its new fashion brands in major fashion event- Fashion on the square 2008 in San Francisco {2}, the UK’s largest retailer Tesco announced at the end of January 2009 its brand new online own labeled fashion project, which is being spearheaded by clothing boss Terry Green and will look different to the retailer’s existing Tesco.com website.



How does proud fashion fit in low price driven supermarkets? Wal-Mart tried the traditional fashion way by launching a higher-priced range with promotion at New York Fashion week and 116-page feature in Vogue, which turned out to be unsuccessful {2}. While Tesco is trying to manipulate RVP with a new tool- online shopping, offering a broad range of selection, the convenience of shopping at home, and low price. Will customers buy the idea? Cheap fashion is not new to sophisticated consumers; brands like H&M, ZARA have been there for decades, what’s Tesco’s key leverage to compete with them? In my opinion, what Tesco is doing is by constructing a separate website and putting the fashion brands only available online, it tries to avoid the perception of buying fashion in supermarkets, which could be perceived as embarrassing by those consumers who can never buy fashion in supermarkets but can not afford to buy high priced items or not any more. By purchasing online at a non Tesco supermarket website, it feels nothing like buying fashion in supermarkets whiles the benefiting from low price. Moreover, different from the impression that average consumer have in mind, which is that in the fashion section in supermarkets, you can only have limited range of practical items, Tesco is offering a much broader range, adding value to the selection part of the new combination of RVP. Will Tesco’s effort appeal to its target segment? The result is soon to come.

1http://www.retail-week.com/multichannel/2009/01/tesco_to_launch_ownlabel_fashion_website.html
2http://www.retail-week.com/News/2008/07/walmart_in_line_for_100m_lift_as_it_ups_ante_in_fashion.html

Warehouse plans to phase out its one-stop shop Outlets


Author: Vaimoana Tapaleao
Article: Warehouse plans to phase out its one stop outlets
Source: NZherald.co.nz
Publication Date: Friday October 10th 2008
By: Bergen Graham

The article by Viamoana Tapaleao is about retail giant The Warehouse’s recent decision to phase out its one stop shop outlets. The decision has been made due to the outlets not achieving the results that the warehouse had originally planned for. The warehouse extra was opened with the intention of creating a one stop shop for consumers where they where able to combine their general Warehouse shopping with there supermarket shopping. The company aimed to achieve a 10% halo benefit in general merchandise and apparel by introducing groceries to their shelves. However after three years in the market The Warehouse has announced it will withdrawal from the market place.

The Warehouse Extra was New Zealand’s first store with an integrated food and non-food product range. These types of stores have seen huge success in other western countries like America and Canada, with Wal-Mart dominating over 35% of the US food marketplace in America [2]. The Warehouse however was not able to follow their success and this is mainly due to their inability to align their services with consumer demands. The retail value proposition (RVP) for the warehouse extra was convenience, price and selection; however it was unsuccessful in combining these three factors to create value within the market place.

The Warehouse Extra may have achieved convince by creating an umbrella store where you are able to buy both food and non food products in one store, but not when it comes to location and accessibility. The three Warehouse Extra stores in New Zealand are located in shopping malls and in industrial regions away from residential areas. This generally means that consumers have to travel quite far to get to The Warehouse and pass supermarkets on their way. In the article a customer quotes “you’ve got to drive out there that is another expense”. The increasing cost of transport and food prices in New Zealand has encouraged consumers to value convenience when it comes to location. The price and selection that The Warehouse offers is also not significant enough to motivate consumers to drive out of there way to buy there groceries specifically from them.

In my opinion the success of Wal-Mart in North and Central America can not be achieved in New Zealand’s market place, as there is just not the demand for it. Supermarkets are already so conveniently located within New Zealand and offer very competitive prices. There are also over five different types of supermarket chains that cater to most of the New Zealand’s differing market groups leaving little room for demand of a new store. Consumption patterns of New Zealanders are also different to that of Americans, who place more value on quantity rather than quality. Mega stores, like Wal-Mart, cater to this demand and are the reason why these types of stores are more widespread in the US market place than in New Zealand.

Reference
The business week magazine viewed on the internet at: http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/03_40/b3852001_mz001.htm (viewed Friday, 3rd may) [2]

The Green Cycle at Mountain Equipment Co-op

In response to: Mountain Equipment Co-op Ontario(TM) stores are now bullfrogpowered(TM), sourced from: http://www.newswire.ca/en/releases/archive/January2009/26/c2170.html

By: Joanna Reardon


Canada’s leading outdoor gear and clothing retailer is staying true to their roots. Mountain equipment Co-op (MEC) has long been a company focused on sustainable retailing – “We’re driven by passion, not profit. We continue to look for ways to protect
our wild spaces and reduce the ecological footprint of our business.” Their efforts over the past 2 years, as outlined in their Accountability Report, include donating 1% of all sales to support Canadian environmental causes, manufacturing products with more eco-friendly processes, reducing emissions from transit by lessening shipments and even promoting greener commuting among employees, and ‘greening their operations’ . The NewsWire article I came across reveals yet another step MEC has taken to reinforce their commitment to the environment. They’ve re-vamped their Ontario retail locations to be in line with their Western counterparts by adopting Bullfrog Power - Canada's only 100% green electricity provider. MEC stores are now completely powered by clean, renewable energy sources like wind and low-impact waterpower. So what does this all mean to their success as a retailer? Why, in economic times as uncertain as these would they invest in ‘greening their operations’?

Growing up ‘Granola’, I can certainly appreciate all that MEC is doing for me as a consumer and for the environment. Then I thought about the average MEC member and realized the proposition could not be better suited to us. Whether or not the Co-op is driven by profits, they’re doing something right. Sales in 2008 were higher than in 2007. Allow me to explain.


A MEC store is an outdoor-person’s Mecca. With a rock-climbing wall positioned prominently in the centre of the store and outdoor ‘toys’ of all kinds surrounding it, there’s a certain je-ne-sais-quoi when you enter the store. There’s no question that their RVP is experience and selection. So how does their newest sustainability initiative reinforce this RVP? The calm lighting and buzz-free power create an experience to mimic the tranquil setting of the outdoors. Customers’ experience is also one of empowerment by feeling as though they’re helping the environment by shopping at MEC. In addition, the product selection is augmented through eco-friendly design. The introduction of a new line identified with a Product Sustainability Symbol signals products to shoppers that are made with organic fibres, through cleaner processes. These products compliment MEC’s assortment while ultimately enforcing the customer’s ‘green’ experience.


Next, consider the fact that MEC is a private label. There is, as we discovered, an upside and a downside to this; however, it seems that MEC is reaping all the upside benefits. Customer loyalty is massive for this outdoor retailer. Because it is a Co-op, shoppers must be members in order to purchase at MEC. Not only is MEC offering a quality brand not available elsewhere, they’re inviting you into their exclusive club in order to shop. Higher margins are also a big plus – not only are they reflected in the overall profits, they allow dollars to be put into sustainability initiatives.

It's all a perfect little green cycle: customer loyalty and higher margins lead to additional profits, which are then translated to greater sustainability initiatives, which in turn lead to a better experience and selection for the customer, ultimately reinforcing customer satisfaction and loyalty. MEC is obviously positioned perfectly in the market to make the cycle work. While it may not be as obvious for other retailers, the benefits of being a sustainable company are real; and I as a consumer would love to see MEC’s practices mimicked across the industry and beyond.

Friday, February 6, 2009

Dunkin’ Donuts and McDonalds vs. Starbucks….Changing RVP?

By: Justin Hartnett

In class we have talked a lot about a company’s retail value proposition in terms of how it wants to position itself on the metrics of selection, price, convenience and experience. It seems that with a lot of companies, once they set and establish their retail value proposition, they more or less continue conducting business that way indefinitely. After all, wouldn’t constantly changing this cause confusion and possible backlash from your customers? For example, Costco, as a mass-quantity retailer, isn’t likely to start offering a better “experience” for customers at the expense of the price and convenience metrics it is renowned for. However, I recently read an article which suggests that in some industries, such as food and beverages, RVP’s are not always set in stone.

Dunkin’ Donuts, essentially the equivalent of Tim Hortons in the United States, is a coffee and doughnut retailer with about 5,769 stores in 34 states and has been primarily known as a lower-quality fast food retailer that generally appeals to price-sensitive consumers. About 63% of their sales come from beverages, with most of this coming from coffee. And with over 1.5 billion cups sold yearly, they are certainly among the leaders in the price-sensitive coffee market. At this point their RVP seems focused mostly on convenience and price. But surprisingly, the company has already created a separate premium coffee line to compete head-to-head with Starbucks, a company losing market share and profitability from product and store over-expansion.

One would think that it would be very hard for a fast food retailer appealing to price-sensitive consumers to also target premium coffee drinkers who might otherwise go to Starbucks. Does this strategy even stand a chance?

Recent results from a taste test suggest that of premium coffee drinkers in 10 U.S. cities, roughly 58% of consumers preferred Dunkin’ Donuts’ coffee versus only 42% for Starbucks! This seems incomprehensible for Starbucks, which had more or less created the premium coffee-drinking market when it was established. Two of the test markets, Los Angeles, where no Dunkin’ Donuts stores exist and Seattle, the headquarters of Starbucks were not considered advantageous originally yet the results suggest otherwise.

The bad news only gets worse with McDonalds also entering the premium coffee market by introducing its McCafe line, complete with cappuccinos and espressos. Now, two fast food retailers which previously would never be confused with higher-quality premium coffee have essentially modified their value proposition to steal market share from the struggling market leader. Both Dunkin’ Donuts and McDonalds have also modified their food product lines to be of higher quality, especially among breakfast foods to compete with Starbucks. These two fast food retailers have essentially placed more emphasis on the selection and experience metrics instead of the price and convenience ones that they are more known for.

If Americans can get premium coffee that tastes as good as Starbucks but at a cheaper price, what becomes of Starbucks? For the premium coffee drinkers who do not have a loyalty to any one particular brand and are slightly more price-sensitive, they may switch over to Dunkin’ Donuts or McDonald’s for their coffee fix, causing Starbucks to lose market share and sales. However, it’s fair to say that there will always be fiercely loyal Starbucks drinkers who are willing to pay higher prices for coffee that they believe tastes the best. Given the number of profitable locations across North America, this is definitely a sizable group.

Nonetheless, this is just an example of how retail value propositions are never really indefinite and can easily change in response to consumer preferences and trends. Starbucks now has two more competitors in the American premium coffee market that it probably never expected.

In terms of Starbucks locations in Canada, I wonder if Tim Hortons has any new plans up their sleeves.

The article can be found at this link: “Dunkin’ Donuts War on Starbucks”: http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/Investing/StockInvestingTrading/dunkin-donuts-war-on-starbucks.aspx

Why Men are Better Shoppers

In our most recent class we debated whether women or men are better shoppers. It is widely believed that women are better shoppers than men. Most people seem to think that because women enjoy shopping more than men, they must be better shoppers. In my opinion, however, this could not be further from the truth. While I may be stereotyping or generalizing, I am simply writing about my experiences.

There are two reasons why I believe men are better shoppers. First, men are more effective shoppers. You may be wondering what it means to be an effective shopper. I believe that effective shoppers buy only what they need, and maximize the value of their purchases. In my experience with female shoppers, they don’t meet either of these criteria. When a woman goes into a mall because she needs a new pair of jeans, there is a pretty good chance that she will return home with three shirts, a purse and a pair of shoes; but no jeans. Plus, she already has five other shirts that look exactly the same. As a result, she will end up wearing her new shirt once and then bury it in her closet. Clearly, she is not maximizing the value of her purchase.

On the other hand, if a man goes into a mall because he needs jeans, there is no way he is leaving that mall without a pair of jeans in his hand. Not only will he buy the jeans, but he will wear the jeans as many times as possible. Furthermore, he won’t walk out of the mall with five other things that he doesn’t really need and will only wear once or twice. Clearly, based on the descriptions that I’ve given, men are more effective shoppers.

Not only are men more effective shoppers, they are also more efficient. I define an efficient shopper as someone who shops effectively while minimizing the time spent shopping. This means that an efficient shopper buys what they need, maximizes value from their purchase and does so in as little time as possible. From my experiences, when a woman walks into a mall, it will be at least a few hours until she leaves. Even if she finds what she wants in 10 minutes, there is no way she is leaving that mall within a couple of hours. Guys, on the other hand, do not waste any time. When a man finds what he is looking for, he is content to make the purchase and return home.

I will admit that in some ways, women are better shoppers than men. For example, men are often very lazy. As a result, they will sometimes buy the first thing that they see simply because they don’t want to look around anymore. This laziness can lead to men purchasing the wrong item or buying something that doesn’t fit. Another area where women have the upper hand is that they are more willing to talk to salespeople. It is often very important to talk to salespeople to get valuable information about certain products. By refusing to ask salespeople for help, men may not make the best purchasing decisions.

While women do have some positive shopping qualities, they are not as effective or efficient in their shopping as men. I think the best case scenario is for a man and a woman to go shopping together. The woman will ensure that they talk to salespeople and take sufficient time to buy the proper items. The man will insist that they only buy what they need and that they get out of the mall as soon as possible. Together they will be a much better shopper than either one would be on their own.

Links:
1) http://www.articlearchives.com/retail-wholesale-trade/retailers/1845590-1.html

2) http://www.brunel.ac.uk/news/pressoffice/pressreleases/2005/cdata/september/savannah

Carrefour Group, can be the new n° 1 retailer of the world?

By Laureen Barbier


For 40 years, the Carrefour Group has grown to become one of the world’s leading retailers. It’s actually the second largest retailer just after the giant Wal-Mart and the largest in Europe. In 2008, sales are estimated to € 97.6 billions. The group knows a solid increase in its sale during this year, especially in its growth markets such as China.
May Carrefour be able to surpass the giant Wal-Mart?


On the one hand, The Carrefour group is currently engaged to a new strategy: they focused on one objective, be among the three leading players in each market where the company is present. They drive their core competencies for growth. They have decided to withdraw the market: Poland, Spain South Korea, Slovakia, and the Czech Republic. Moreover, they have assured their position by way of tactical acquisitions in Brazil, Poland and Spain.²


This strategy leds to double the store openings in existing and emerging markets. The group, currently, operates four main grocery store formats: hypermarkets, supermarkets, hard discount and convenience stores. It has over 15,000 stores under company-operates or franchise.


Carrefour is undeniably better than Wal-Mart in certain aspects of retailing business. The former CEO Daniel Bernard (replaced in January 1st 2009 by Lars Olofsson) says: “They learn (Wal-Mart) from us in fresh food and merchandising”.
The most significant success and competitive advantage that Carrefour has is their presence in markets where the US giant was late to come into like Asia. For example, the Group has 100 stores in China, twice more than Wal-Mart.
"Carrefour is the world's most successful international retailer," says Jaime Vasquez, an industry analyst at Salomon Smith Barney in London, adding, "Wal-Mart has no track record outside North America." The French retailer has built its empire in over 29 countries. By contrast, Wal-Mart operates only in 10 countries.
In Addition, the Carrefour group puts its customers as the center of their objective. They simplified its organization, to give more independence and freedom to stores managers in order to adapt their business to the needs area. They have increased its service offering in order to expand the customer choice, to respond to different customer lifestyles.


On the other hand, Carrefour Group faced to challenges that may affect their current strategy of expansion.

Indeed, The Empire is shaking in its foundation, I mean, in the French Market
for few years, more and more French consumers have switched its favorite hypermarkets in favor to discount chains such as German’s Aldi and Lidl. With the current crisis, this challenge increase and the Group has reacted already with the development of hard discount stored Ed in France and Dia abroad. However is it enough to satisfied new consumer‘s habits? This new strategy hasn’t slowed the new competitors already set up on the outlet market. Some store sales had fallen at 4 %. . Carrefour sales slowed to 0.7% gain compared to 10% gain in 2008. And last month, the French retailer had issued a profit warning in response to falling demand from consumers and fierce promotions that it used to lure shoppers to its stores. °

Abroad, the situation changed and competitors appear. They have pulled out of some countries where it has struggled; and concentrated on key markets like Latin America and Asia. In fact, sales have slowed down in West European countries such as Spain which has boosted results last year .In China, the Group want to increase the number of store opening to boost sales because of the global recession.. The country knows ,for the first time, a slowing economic growth and the projections indicate that this situation will continue. When there is a crisis, people look to price. So the retailer has decided to drop prices and make more promotions in order to compensate. “Expansion in China is fine, but if you put it in a larger context the market still represents only a slow single digit percentage of sales,” said Christopher Hogbin analyst at Sanford C. Bernstein in London.³

Finally, even if the biggest French retailer has always failed to enter in last market where is not present: the US market, their final aim for the Group in a long term view, is to win the global commercial battle. And I think they are closed to reach this objective if the economic background doesn’t modify the rules of the retailing business.

²http://www.carrefour.com/cdc/group/current-news/2008-sales-en.html

³http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601089&sid=a9cs2JLTJ8O8&refer=china

°http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/04_41/b3903075_mz054.htm

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Understand Your Customers….NOW!

Class this week was focused around the science of shopping – the way that consumers react to store layouts, product placement and packaging. In a world that is filled with constant distractions, it has become essential for retailers and brands to ensure that customers are aware of their products, that the products are visible, and that consumers are enticed or led to where the products can be purchased.

The average attention span of people in society decreases almost daily, which makes understanding consumer behaviour as important as advertising or promotions. Customer experience and the ability to capture the attention of customers is a prominent issue, but before capturing attention is possible, retailers must now focus on understanding where the customers will be, and how they will act, in order to ensure products are located in areas that consumers are likely to be in, and that buying patterns of certain customer segments are capitalized on through up-selling and strategically placing associated products together.

Retailers must now put themselves in the shoes of customers to ensure that buyers can not only find what they need, but that they are subjected to seeing what they came in for, or more importantly, what they did not come in for, but are likely to buy, based on the general buying patterns of studied target segments. Retailers cannot expect consumers to come into their stores and leave with merchandise that they had no intention of buying, if they don’t find a way of bringing the consumers to that merchandise, and making them believe that they need it.

Successful stores and companies have long studied consumer behaviour and buying patterns in order to maximize their efficiencies and profits, through catering store layouts and product offerings to customer demand and subconscious shopping behaviour. In today’s busy and technological world however, more in depth research can be done in order to maximize the shopping experience for customers, in turn maximizing sales for retailers. Most successful retailers are placing ever more importance on these trends, and are using technology to precisely predict consumer behaviour, in order to offer the best and most lucrative experience possible to consumers and potential consumers. Huge retailers such as Wal-Mart and Safeway have recently turned to virtual market researchers to better understand their customers. Red Dot Square Solutions has developed a virtual reality software solution which uses 3D simulations integrated with real-time eye tracking and analysis to help retailers and manufacturers test and design store layouts, promotions and product and pack designs.[1] These retailers understand the importance of catering to customer desires, but also to customer behaviours. More specifically, they understand the importance of understanding their target markets’ behaviours.

Understanding consumer thought process, as well general subconscious behaviour, provides retailers with a significant advantage, as they are able to precisely target those in specific target markets and capture attention. There is still a lack of importance placed on the study of consumer trends for many retailers, however the successes of some of the best performing retailers in the world truly shows the effectiveness of understanding consumer behaviour. Those retailers who have not yet taken an in-depth look at the way the layout of their store and their advertisements and promotions affect the behaviours of current and potential customers must immediately spend the time necessary to understand better understand their customers, and consumers’ behaviour in general, to better service and target consumers. Others have already taken the next step by scientifically measuring consumer behaviour trends; those who continue to negate the importance of these studies will not be able to survive in a retailing world where the majority better understand consumers, and run their businesses accordingly. There may be a tomorrow for those who don’t place an emphasis on the study of consumers, but retailers who strive to better understand their customers will slowly capture market share from the slower movers, through better positioning and marketing of products based on the understanding of the conscious and subconscious wants and behaviours of the modern consumer. Better business is by understanding and catering to customers; it is time that all retailers realize this, and reap the benefits.

[1] http://www.mrweb.com/drno/news9519.htm