Welcome to the the Ivey HBA Retail Marketing Management blog. Retail marketing is an exciting, dynamic, important, and very visible aspect of the overall field of marketing. Throughout the year, students will be posting comments regarding contemporary retailing issues. Although this is intended to be used by Bus 4411 students, industry marketing professionals are also invited to join in if they like.

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

H&M offers a value proposition that succeeds during recession

Hennes & Mauritz (H&M) is a Swedish clothing company established in 1947. The company's business concept has been to offer fashion and quality to customers at the best possible price. First, the company started with only women’s apparel but it has turned into a large chain selling men’s and children’s clothing and accessories. Unlike most retailers at the moment, H&M has succeeded to gain strong profits during the time of financial crisis. This is what makes H&M interesting: what is that they offer to consumers that appeals to them even during recession? How can H&M promise to create thousands of new jobs when others are sacking their employees?


H&M’s retail value proposition is centered mostly on low product prices and a good selection. But I would say that H&M is not successful at the moment only because of low prices: H&M is not only about that. H&M has created a strong brand that is associated with high fashion and top designers. Being associated with names like Madonna, Kate Moss, Karl Lagerfeld and Stella McCartney, H&M has really created something unique. The fact that a company is offering low price products, doesn’t necessarily mean that the brand has to be a cheap one too. H&M has put a lot of effort into building a brand associated with top fashion but yet has kept the prices low for most products. Most popular clothing brands from the same price range cannot be seen in small boutiques or runways in Italy like some of H&M’s products can be. H&M proofs how a strong brand can be built even if the company is mostly selling low price products.



Of course, nothing is only black and white and H&M definitely isn’t known as a luxurious brand in most countries. For example, when the Finnish fashion brand Marimekko signed a licensing agreement for fabrics with H&M in 2008, there were speculations about how the connection to H&M would affect Marimekko’s image as high quality brand. At the moment, I would say that Marimekko is feeling satisfied with its choice to work together with one of the blooming retailers in the fashion industry.


I would say that convenience is to some extent important to H&M’s value proposition too. Most of the shops are situated in shopping malls or conveniently in the center of a city. However, convenience is not what they’re offering to customers everywhere. For example in Stockholm, in the very heart of H&M business, H&M doesn’t serve clients with a one stop policy. There are several smaller stores in downtown Stockholm and you can’t get all styles and products from just one store.



To conclude, one of H&M’s keys to success has been its ability to offer low prices while staying flexible and building a strong brand. You don’t have to be similar in every country even though you are a large chain: some countries want more convenience; some may need more references with high fashion. H&M has understood how to serve different needs without compromising their core competence in economies of scale and low prices.


1. http://www.thelocal.se/17220/20090129/
2.https://newsclient.omxgroup.com/cdsPublic/viewDisclosure.action?disclosureId=245141&messageId=279124

Tuesday, February 3, 2009

Lululemon's Walking, Talking Billboards

In response to: Canadian Business Week Online, Toned and Ready: Lululemon Transitions

By: Rosalind Copp

In the Candian Business Week article, the author applauded Lululemon for their lack of traditional marketing and reliance on word of mouth. It is true, at first glance it is appears that the company has no marketing plan. They have not engaged in any traditional forms of advertising, they do not promote sales at their stores and they never have in-store promotions. They even renamed their internal marketing department, labelling it community relations. However, a company that is that successful has a clear and effective marketing plan. They want to appear removed from a traditional corporation with their yoga wear and healthy lifestyle. Traditional marketing and advertising would not fit with their brand image. Instead of pushing their products on to consumers they have made consumers come to them. Lululemon first began doing this by giving their products to people they feel represent their products the best. Yoga teachers and fitness instructors who sport their free Lululemon apparel in their classes and who advocate the products for their high quality have helped create to positive word of mouth and a buzz about the products in the yoga world. However, Lululemon cannot rely on yogis alone, their products must be appealing for those not into fitness to be as popular as they are. Thier mission is simple, let our symbol been seen as often as possible, and on as many people as possible.

By far the most influential promoters of Lululemon are the store employees. This is probably where the company invested the money they would have otherwise spent on marketing their products. Employees of Lululemon go through vigorous health training and do free yoga during their lunch hour. They are encouraged to eat healthy meals, they are not allowed to smoke and it would be a major faux-pas for an employee to ever been seen eating fast food in a food court or anywhere that they could be associated with the store and brand. Lululemon employees must embody what every Lululemon customer aspires to be, happy and healthy. Like the yoga instructors, Lululemon employees are the walking, talking billboards for the yoga products. Lululemon has relied greatly on word of mouth, and have ensured this by placing their products in the hands of the right people. As well, I would argue that any attractive girl who wears their clothing to work out in, or just for everyday use is a walking, talking billboard for Lululemon. The products themselves are created so that they accentuate specific areas of the female body and definitely are very flattering on some women. This is revolutionary for sweatpants which in the past have been unflattering and associated with laziness.

In order to truly understand the value of a pair of sweatpants that costs $90, women have to see them on someone else first. They have to see how good they look on someone else, and really want those pants (or sports bra etc) so they can look that good too. They will be willing to pay more if they can look as good as that woman they say in yoga or at the gym the other day. Women tend to check out other women more than men do, and they are way more likely to notice when another women is wearing something flattering or something they like. Advertisements alone focusing on a woman’s assets would not create a positive brand image for the company and consumers would probably be offended, but that is one of the things that people love about the pants. It would just be another advertisement where sex was used to sell something. It doesn’t fit with the brand image and it wouldn’t resonate with the consumer group Lululemon is trying to target. By having fit, healthy, attractive women sporting their clothing and working in the stores Lululemon is able to show off their products in a way an advertisement or mannequin never could.

The employees at Lululemon are not models, they are not stick-thin, they are healthy young women who give off a happy, easy-going vibe. The entire Lululemon store gives off this vibe. It is inviting and laid out in a way that’s easy to for women to browse. The store is completely wood in the inside many with fountains and bamboo trees; it feels like you are in nature, not in the mall. Finding your size is easy, the product is displayed on a mannequin on top of a shelf with each size having its on shelf below. This lets the women who know what they want able to get what they want quickly and get out. This also allows the store to make efficient use of lower shelves since women must scan down the shelves for their size. Lululemon has made full use of the otherwise forgotten wall space. For a shopper who is unsure of what they want, employees are knowledgeable in all the product areas and add a personal touch to the shopping experience by learning and writing down your name on the change room door. When employees check to see how something fits, they call you by your name, like your friend. You get a sense that employees there care, about their health, about the environment, about you.

However, again this is all part of Lululemon’s hidden but effective marketing scheme. Once you examine the store closer it becomes very apparent that everything is made to appear free-spirited and easy going but everything has a very specific place and purpose. The front of the store is where all the very bright, expensive and usually new items appear. There is no visible price, or signage telling you how much something costs as that would make the products appear of a lesser quality and the high prices would steer many people away. All the items at the front of the store are fashion items for working out, the necessities (sports bras, shorts etc) are located at the back of the store. This forces women who are also by nature impulse buyers to walk by all the bags, sweatshirts, and of course the pants in order for them to get to what they really need for working out. Interestingly, sales items are placed with similar items in the store (pants on sale with non-sale pants) instead of in one location or at the back. Also, sale tags are very small and most of the time not even noticeable on specific items. Lululemon never promotes sales, or holds a store wide sale at their retail locations nor does it promote the sale items within the store. They do not want women to browse a sale rack, they want women to buy the most expensive item possible and if they happen to fall upon a sale item then so be it, but they make it as difficult as possible to do so.

Lululemon’s latest non-marketing trick is the bags you receive when you purchase their clothing. The bags are environmentally friendly, and re-usable. They make perfect gym bags (far more fashionable than a duffle bag), and have the Lululemon symbol sprawled all over them with sayings like “live, love, do yoga” (inadvertent actual saying : “live, love, wear Lululemon”). The bags promote everything the brand stands for and they are useful. You get the feeling that you got something extra with the product you purchased. And indeed you have. Although you may have only spent $ 8 on a headband at the Lululemon, you now have also become a walking, talking billboard for the company.

Monday, February 2, 2009

‘Just Enough Operating System’

Mass-Customization

Today we discussed the concept of Mass Customization, where corporations find that perfect median between adapting to individual customers and still being able to manufacture at a mass level to realize the majority of the economies of scale. Some of the products we decided as a class that worked best customized were things like shoes, cars and computers (in the case of Dell). A recent article discusses the possibility of customizing one’s actual Operating System. There has been some personal customization from individual users, but they have often been unauthorized by the vendor. Can this be done at the mass level? A better approach is to create an environment using only the Operating System resources needed for a particular application set. This is known as JeOS (just enough operating system). The question is: How do we move to a JeOS environment? Particularly with Linux, although it has been designed to be customized, very few organizations take advantage of this capability. Linux's modular architecture is ideal for creating JeOS because it can be easily stripped down and modified.


Advantages


Mass customization would be able to realize the benefits and efficiency of mass production, but with ability to tailor an OS for different use cases. And because this tailoring is achieved through the arrangement of standard Linux components, it is fully supported. Other advantages include:

  • Reduce Maintenance Costs
  • Strengthened Security
  • Greater Agility – helps IT reduce time required to deploy new servers



The future:


All that's needed now are tools to make mass customization a reality. We didn't achieve mass customization of cars until Ford thought up the assembly line. We need the equivalent of the assembly line in the OS world: tools that provide rapid, fully supported mass market efficiency, reliability and consistency, while allowing for individuality.


My thoughts:


When is it right to customize at the mass level? This is something that we discussed in class, and is Linux at a good place to do so? I would argue that this is most definitely a profitable and logical progression. This differs from some of the examples that we talked in class, because this actually makes financial sense. Companies would definitely go for a cheaper, easier to learn and easier to maintain system if that is all that they require. Where in the Adidas or even cars example the mass customization was being done purely for ‘looking cool’ or superficial reasons, here we see a more functional approach behind it. This parallels more of the customization that we saw in Dell. Where different users require different things from their computer, taking that one step lower, different companies require different applications in their Operating System.


For the multiple advantages discussed above this will work. The pressure is now on Linux on developing a system where then can build a manufacturing process which can accommodate this production method. What if they are able to? A question was posed today, that can this be a competitive advantage, especially with such large competition in the Operating System market? It was also mentioned in class today that it could not in fact be a competitive advantage most of the time, but this may be one time where it could be possible. The fact is that the Linux Operating System from a design perspective has an advantage that it has not currently been exploiting. Once Linux is able to create a method of mass customizing its Operating Systems they will have a clear edge over Windows or any other system. The following questions arise: Does Windows have the capability of doing this? How long will it take for other Operating Systems to match this personal-approach? How permanent can Linux’s first mover advantage last?


Regardless of the answer to these questions, this is a prime case of a product that is ready to be mass customized, and Linux is at the front of the line to be the first to do it.

Private Label Clothing During a Recession

During a recession, basic economics state that a slowing economy will lead to less disposable income for the average consumer. With shrinking disposable income, prevailing economic theory is that consumers will cut back on normal extravagant items and spend on goods of necessity; oil for their car, cheap food and health-care products for the family, and heating/air-conditioning for homes are all examples of goods the average individual will continue to purchase regardless of fluctuations in disposable income. Given its obvious absence from this exclusive list, the retail sector has relatively large exposure to any recession. While individuals need things like clothing or food, none of us actually need a particular style or brand, no matter how often young children complain to their parents. Taking an example like retail clothing, it should seem pretty obvious that during the current recession, people cutting their spending (which are most of North Americans) will purchase cheap, non-branded shirts and pants. Thus, private label clothing will thrive during a declining economy. That simple! Great, we’re done here.

Or are we? A recent Reuters article made mention of the fact that private labels are suffering a great deal from the current recession. As a result, brands are beginning to seize a greater percentage of floor space in department stores then beforehand. To steal a line from a popular TV show character, “what in the deuce is happening?”

There happens to be two forces at work here, both representing the typical usual suspects in any retailing transaction; consumers and retailers. Consumers don’t exactly behave the way that normal economic theory dictates that they would during a recession. Instead of what most people assume—that the average individual would spend less on each item of clothing for example—the average individual is instead cutting back on the quantity of what they are buying instead of purchasing cheaper clothing. With shrinking disposable income, the critical nature behind every single purchase purchase becomes magnified. Customers are now thinking “if this is my only purchase, I want it to be something special”. The type of clothing which would satisfy this thought process is most certainly NOT a generic private label piece of clothing. It is for this reason that one should expect recognized high-end brand names like Burberry, Canada Goose, Christian Audiger and even Prada or Gucci to continue to perform despite the harsh realities of the North America economy. These brands, and others like them, are instantly recognizable and carry a strong cache with the general public. That, of course, does not mean premium brands are positioned to succeed during these economic times. While it may sometimes be true, it is a foolish leap to assume that premium and instantly recognizable are always one and the same in the retailing world.

The other part of the equation is the retailers themselves. The basis for giving floor space to private label brands was their relatively high margins compared to normal premium brands. With discounts and sales pervasive across the retailing industry, this competitive advantage is shrinking giving retailers little reason to feature private labels as predominantly as before.
It is important to realize the true effect that the recession has on private labels and recognizable brands respectively; private labels are not necessarily counter cyclical, and brand names are not necessarily pro-cyclical. By understanding that these pre-conceived notions don’t always apply, retailers can better prepare themselves to effectively manage through a recession.



SOURCE: http://in.reuters.com/article/businessNews/idINIndia-37521320090119?pageNumber=3&virtualBrandChannel=0

A Shame Attached to Luxury

Written By: Courtney Lerman

There have been many articles written and news reports broadcasted that focus on the threat the current recession poses to retail sales of luxury goods. Naturally, when consumers feel their wealth has decreased or is threatened, they refrain from purchasing expensive non-staple items. As a result, many high-end retailers were offering significant discounts to try to move inventory through their stores over the 2008 holiday season. An interesting perspective on the future of luxury stores was presented in Rita Zekas’ article, “Thrift Store Chic” that was published in The Toronto Star on January 22nd.

Expensive retail stores focus their retail value proposition mainly on experience. Clearly prices are not a selling point and neither is convenience; people will pay high prices and travel long distances to shop at these upscale retailers. For some department stores, selection may be a focus, but the main reason these stores can charge astronomical prices is due to the customer experience.

Consumers will pay the $1,000 for a Gucci bag because it portrays a certain image. If this is so, then one may wonder why Prada shoppers have been requesting unmarked bags to carry their purchases. Zekas claims there has been a reverse of snobbism, “shoppers brag about what they snag at a low price”.

During a time when unemployment is hitting the middle class by the masses causing many to lose their homes, the positive experience associated with carrying a Chanel shopping bag has been whisked away – consumers are instead embarrassed. Shoppers have become weary of what others will think of their overindulgence and unnecessary spending when so many are suffering. Zekas describes this attitude as “a shame attached to luxury”. The main value proposition luxury brands had is threatened, and without this positive image, they have little to offer consumers.

Some retailers may hope this is temporary and as consumer confidence rises the “saving money” fad will end. However, there is evidence that this may develop into a long-term attitude. According to Tyler Cowen for the New York Times, a recession can alter cultural attitudes and behaviors for decades into the future. An example Cowen describes is the shift to inexpensive forms of entertainment during the Great Depression in the 1930s. Listening to the radio and playing board games were trends that rapidly grew during the depression and remained until the 1950s.

As consumers stay away from expensive brand named items out of fear of appearing overindulgent and unsympathetic, is there hope for luxury stores in the future? How long will this fad last? Will Burberry and Louis Vuitton be able to adapt? Without the positive experience associated with the brands and decreasing consumer wealth, it will be difficult for luxury retailers to maintain their sales figures.


Resources:
The Toronto Star:
http://www.thestar.com/living/article/574815 - "Thrift Store Chic" by Rita Zekas published January 22nd, 2009

The New York Times:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/01/business/01view.html?ref=business - "Recession Can Change a Way of Life" by Tyler Cowen published January 31, 2009

American Apparel…a clothing retailer or magazine shop?

I have to be honest. I am not an American Apparel (AA) shopper, however I have been exposed to their marketing and advertising techniques, have seen their stores pop up and I have done a few projects on their CEO Dov Charney and his dubious behavior. Only after reading about this most recent incident, do I feel they have made a grave error in judgment that may negatively affect their sales negatively incorporating experience into their retail value proposition.

The incident as described by the Globe and Mail[1] is as follows. A mother goes into American Apparel in Vancouver with her 13-year-old daughter, and the mother notices a BUTT magazine[2] hanging out of a backpack on a mannequin. What caught her attention was the cover of a naked man walking away. She took it out to look at and opened it to find a two-page spread of two males engaged in some sort of sexual act. The latter event really upset her; she ended up confronting the staff who immediately blamed corporate headquarters. I guess I should also mention that AA also sells copies of the magazine at their stores.

AA is known as a unique apparel company who manufactures solely in the US, and promotes a sweatshop free environment. Over the last 6 years or so they have developed a very controversial reputation with the CEO being known to walk around the office in his underwear, objectify and sleep with his female employees and the list goes on. As a company AA are known for their scandalous and revealing advertisements (many photo shoots done by Dov at his home in his basement), their store décor and the hipster retail employees.

The experience observed at retail shops, is developed primarily from the vision of its founders and leaders, and this totally applies for AA. In my opinion, while Mr. Charney’s personal behavior has not seemed to deter buyers, AA has taken the experience too far, and this may negatively affect their retail sales. It’s one thing to have highly sexual advertisements in magazines and on billboards promoting your merchandise, since consumers are constantly bombarded and desensitized to many of these images. However, to have BUTT magazine available to any of your consumers will and has really offended them on a personal level and passed their threshold of comfort. While there may be a fine line between pornographic and sexualizing images, companies should be aware that pornography is still considered taboo by many and will therefore not be accepted. AA targets mainly female consumers who range from young girls to their mothers. There are very few people that I know (girls or guys, mothers or fathers) that would feel comfortable walking into a clothing store and being exposed to pornography.

I am confident that consumers do shop ethically. Although many people can view AA as being ethical (based on their sweatshop free and manufactured in America motto), I think being exposed to pornography without asking for it trumps their super ethical supply chain.

The Globe and Mail attempted to contact both the Montreal and LA head offices of AA however did not get any response back.

Whether you shop at AA or not, I recommend that you read up on both their strategy and the CEO Dov Charney.

[1]http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20090115.wbcapparel15/EmailBNStory/National/
[2]http://www.buttmagazine.com/

Sunday, February 1, 2009

Recession Proof, really?

In our first lecture the rebirth of convenience stores was identified a s a current trend in retail marketing, however conveniencestorenews.com warns that the recession will negatively effect gasoline, tobacco, candy and snack sales, all of which are convenience stores’ staples.[1] This got me thinking, do recession-proof retailers, or consumer goods actually exist, and if so what retail value propositions do these offer?

Gasoline and tobacco are considered inelastic goods, as demand is not sensitive to a change in price, however conveniencestorenews.com claims that there customers are selecting lower grades of gasoline, cheaper brands of tobacco and reducing the quantity purchased in a single transaction, in an attempt to spend less. It would be hard to argue that inelastic goods are not recession proof, however more specifically; it seems that the lower end brands of inelastic goods are the true recession proofs. The retail value proposition (RVP) they offer is the experience or use the consumer is seeking, along with price.

On the other hand, candy and snacks are usually impulse purchases and it seems feasible to assume that consumption of these goods will decrease in a recession as it is an easy, and obvious way for consumers to reduce their spending, for this reason I would argue they are not recession proof. However it could be argued that consumption of these products will increase during a recession as consumers substitute eating out or going out for a much cheaper night in with these goods, in this case the retail value proposition is price.

A retailer whom is thriving in the current economic climate is Amazon, who has just reported its most successful holiday season ever. The Chief Executive comments that this has been achieved because of Amazon’s relentless efforts to offer customers a great selection and low prices, including free shipping offers.[2] The products offered by Amazon are by no means inelastic, Amazon’s increased sales are a result of stealing market share from competitors, not because the category has experienced sales growth, therefore it is Amazon’s and not its goods’ RVP which is recession proof. Their offerings of price and selection and convenience are irresistible for consumers in the current climate.

It would hard to dispute that an RVP offering price in the current economic climate is attractive to consumers, the majority of which become more price sensitive during a recession, however in order for brands and retailers to recession proof their selves they must offer more than just low prices. Other elements of the RVP must also be on offer available to customers. Amazon have demonstrated that a retailer selling non-commodity and elastic goods can still thrive during a recession, they have done this by offering three elements of the RVP. It seems likely that convenience stores stocked with a wide selection of goods, including cheaper brands will do best as they can offer three elements of the RVP.



[1] Are C-Stores Recession Proof? http://www.csnews.com/csn/print/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1003789103

[2] Profits Rise at Amazon as Shoppers Seek Deals. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/30/technology/companies/30amazon.html?scp=1&sq=recession%20proof%20retailing&st=Search